top of page

H.H. Holmes Didn't Fall Because of a Murder Castle. He Fell Because of Frank Geyer

3 hours ago
7 min read

H.H. Holmes in a bowler hat beside his Englewood Castle building and a portrait of Philadelphia detective Frank Geyer

On 17 November 1894, 132 years ago today, Pinkerton agents arrested a smooth-talking, neatly moustached man in Boston. He called himself H.H. Holmes. He wasn't arrested for murder. He was arrested over an insurance swindle, and at that point nobody had the faintest idea he'd killed anyone at all.


You probably know the version of Holmes that came later: the Murder Castle, the trapdoors, the hundreds of World's Fair tourists gassed in soundproof rooms. Most of that's legend. The story that actually put a rope round his neck is far less theatrical and a lot more human. It's about a grieving Philadelphia detective, a bundle of children's letters that were never posted and a summer spent knocking on doors across the American Midwest and into Canada.


Old photograph of H.H. Holmes's three-storey corner building on 63rd Street in Englewood, Chicago, with shopfronts at street level
Holmes's building on 63rd Street in Englewood, Chicago, later nicknamed the Murder Castle

Forget the Murder Castle for a Minute

The Holmes legend has grown so much in the telling that it's hard to see the real man under it. The claim that he killed up to 200 people gets repeated everywhere, but historian Adam Selzer, who spent years going through original newspaper archives, could only confirm around nine victims. Every one of them was somebody Holmes already knew. None of them were random fairgoers lured off the street.



Even the famous name is a later invention. The building on 63rd Street in Englewood was mostly called the Holmes Castle until the 1930s, and while it did have some secret rooms and passages, the city already knew about them before the 1893 World's Fair even opened. Selzer argues that an untrained new Chicago police chief convinced himself and the newspapers that the building held the answer to every unsolved crime in town.


So what actually brought Holmes down? Not Chicago at all. It was a dead carpenter in Philadelphia and one very stubborn detective.


Victorian portrait photograph of Benjamin Pitezel, Holmes's accomplice in the insurance fraud
Benjamin Pitezel

A Fake Death That Became a Real One

Benjamin Pitezel was a carpenter with a drink problem and a criminal record who'd been Holmes's sidekick in assorted frauds for years. In 1894 the pair cooked up a new one. Pitezel would set himself up in Philadelphia as a patent dealer called B.F. Perry, take out a $10,000 policy with the Fidelity Mutual Life Association and then "die" in a lab accident. A cadaver disfigured beyond recognition would be swapped in and his wife Carrie would collect.


Holmes had other plans. In early September 1894 he knocked Pitezel out with chloroform and set him on fire in the Callowhill Street house, making it look like an explosion had gone wrong. He collected the insurance money, then convinced Carrie her husband was alive and hiding out, and handed her just $500 of the payout.


The whole thing might've worked if Holmes hadn't stiffed a train robber. Earlier that year he'd spent a short stretch in a St Louis prison over a separate fraud, where he shared a cell block with outlaw Marion Hedgepeth. Holmes promised Hedgepeth $500 for the name of a lawyer who'd help with the insurance plan, then never paid up. Hedgepeth, understandably miffed, told the authorities everything. The insurers called in the Pinkertons and the hunt was on.


Three Children Who Simply Vanished

Here's where the case turns from a grubby insurance fiddle into something genuinely horrible. Holmes persuaded Carrie Pitezel to let him take three of her children, Alice, Nellie and little Howard, supposedly to see their father. Then he went on the move.


Newspaper sketches of the three Pitezel children, Alice, Howard and Nellie, drawn side by side
Newspaper sketches of the Pitezel children

For weeks he shuttled across the Midwest and into Canada with three separate travelling parties: the Pitezel children, Carrie with her eldest daughter and baby, and his own latest wife, Georgiana Yoke. Each group was kept in a different lodging, sometimes only streets apart. None of them knew the others were there. In Detroit he rented a house and started digging a hole in the basement until the neighbours got curious.


By the time the Pinkertons caught up with him in Boston, the children had disappeared. Holmes calmly insisted they were travelling with a woman called Minnie Williams. Minnie Williams, as it turned out, had been missing herself for well over a year.



Enter Frank Geyer

Holmes was convicted of insurance fraud fairly quickly, but the missing children nagged at everyone. In June 1895 the Philadelphia police sent Detective Frank Geyer to retrace Holmes's steps. Erik Larson later described him as a "big man with a pleasant, earnest face", and he was carrying more than most. Larson's account notes that Geyer had lost his own wife and daughter not long before, which gives the search a weight it's hard to read about.


Sepia portrait of Philadelphia detective Frank Geyer with a moustache and bow tie
Frank Geyer

Geyer's secret weapon was a stack of letters. Alice and Nellie had written home to their mother throughout the trip, and Holmes had taken the letters off them and kept them, never posting a single one. Those letters gave Geyer the children's route almost town by town.


What followed was proper old-fashioned police work. No fingerprints, no forensics worth the name, just hotel registers, boarding house landladies and estate agents. Geyer worked his way through Cincinnati, Indianapolis, Chicago and Detroit, matching dates in the letters to names in the ledgers, and the trail kept pointing north.


A Crawlspace on St Vincent Street

In Toronto, Geyer teamed up with local detective Alf Cuddy and started going through every rental agent in the city. Eventually they found a small two-storey cottage at 16 St Vincent Street, near Yonge and College, that a man matching Holmes's description had rented the previous October. A neighbour remembered him borrowing a spade.


On 15 July 1895 Geyer crawled under the house and pushed a shovel into a patch of soft soil. A few feet down he found Alice and Nellie. The coroner's best guess was that Holmes had locked the girls in a large trunk and pumped in gas. Nellie's feet had been removed, almost certainly because her club foot would've made her easy to identify.



Geyer couldn't get word to Carrie in time, so she read about it in the paper. When she arrived in Toronto by train from Detroit she was mobbed by a crowd of around 500 people. The city was so shaken that the sisters were buried almost in secret, in a single grave at St James Cemetery. The funeral procession was just two children's hearses and one closed carriage, carrying Carrie and the two detectives.


Howard and the Irvington Chimney

That still left Howard. Alice's letters had stopped mentioning her brother after Indianapolis, so Geyer went back and started again, working through rental after rental in the city and its suburbs. It took weeks.


The breakthrough came in Irvington, then a village just outside Indianapolis, where Holmes had rented a cottage in October 1894. In the chimney and around the old stove, searchers found charred bone fragments and teeth, along with a few small belongings that Carrie later recognised as her son's. Howard, just ten years old, had been murdered there on 10 October 1894, two weeks before his sisters died in Toronto.



Why Geyer Matters More Than the Castle

Here's the bit the legend tends to skip. It was Geyer's discoveries in Toronto that prompted the closer look at Holmes's Chicago building in the first place. The castle stories, the vats of acid and the gas chambers all grew out of a search that only happened because one Philadelphia detective had already done the hard part. The sensational version got the headlines. Geyer's version got the conviction.


Holmes went on trial in Philadelphia in the autumn of 1895, charged only with the murder of Benjamin Pitezel. He was found guilty. Geyer wrote up the whole hunt as a book in 1896, and on 12 April that year the Philadelphia Inquirer ran his account alongside Holmes's own confession. When Geyer died years later, his funeral was attended by hundreds of police officers and detectives.


Sepia newspaper engraving of men standing on the gallows platform at Holmes's execution in Moyamensing Prison
A newspaper engraving of Holmes's execution at Moyamensing Prison, 7 May 1896

The Cash-for-Confession Deal and a Concrete Coffin

That confession is where a lot of the myth really took off. Holmes sold it to the Hearst papers for a sum usually given as $7,500, though some put it as high as $10,000. In it he owned up to 27 murders. The trouble was that several of the people he claimed to have killed were still alive at the time. On the gallows he changed his story again and said he'd only killed two.

Holmes was hanged at Moyamensing Prison on 7 May 1896. Across the Atlantic, Britain was dealing with its own Victorian monster that same spring, with baby farmer Amelia Dyer going to the gallows just a month later.


Holmes was terrified of grave robbers selling his body, so he asked for his coffin to be encased in concrete. That request fed rumours for over a century that he'd dodged the noose and escaped. In 2017 his descendants finally had him dug up at Holy Cross Cemetery. Penn Museum archaeologists found an empty wooden coffin and then a second one underneath, and the remains inside were confirmed as Holmes's. One descendant, Jeff Mudgett, still reckons his ancestor was also Jack the Ripper, a theory most historians don't take seriously.



The concrete held, the body was his and the legend carries on regardless. But if you want the real story of H.H. Holmes, skip the trapdoors. Look at a detective crouched in a Toronto crawlspace with a shovel, a handful of unposted letters in his pocket, refusing to give up on three kids everyone else had stopped looking for.

Suggested Reading

Want to go further? These are the best books on the real Holmes and the men who chased him.


H.H. Holmes: The True History of the White City Devil by Adam Selzer. The myth-busting one. Selzer went back to the original newspapers and records and separates what really happened from what got invented later.


The Devil in the White City by Erik Larson. The bestseller that made Holmes a household name again. Gripping on Geyer's hunt, though it leans on some of the older legends.


The Holmes-Pitezel Case by Frank P. Geyer. Geyer's own 1896 account of the search, written while it was all still raw. Dated in places but nothing beats hearing it from the man himself.


As an Amazon Associate, Utterly Interesting earns from qualifying purchases.

You Might Also Like

Sources

  1. The Enduring Mystery of H.H. Holmes, America's First Serial Killer, Smithsonian Magazine

  2. Is all that stuff about H.H. Holmes true?, Time Out Chicago

  3. 'True History' of H.H. Holmes Examines Life, Career of Serial Killer, WTTW News

  4. The H.H. Holmes murders on St. Vincent Street, Spacing Toronto

  5. Scary, But True: Serial Killer H.H. Holmes Foiled By Insurer, InsuranceNewsNet

  6. H.H. Holmes, Encyclopaedia Britannica

  7. Doc's trail of blood ended in Toronto St. James gravesite, Toronto Star (archive copy)

  8. Frank Geyer, Prabook

  9. The Devil in the White City, Part 4, Chapter 3 summary, LitCharts

  10. Etta Alice Pitezel memorial with 1895 newspaper transcripts, Find a Grave

  11. H.H. Holmes: Philadelphia Inquirer, April 12, 1896, DVRBS Camden History

  12. Did Serial Killer H.H. Holmes Really Build a 'Murder Castle'?, History.com

  13. H.H. Holmes gravesite dig, NBC10 Philadelphia

  14. A death-defying dig at the grave of a serial killer, PhillyVoice

 
 
bottom of page