top of page

Mensur: The German Student Duels Where the Scar Was the Prize

Aug 20, 2020
7 min read

Updated: Nov 10

Mensur fencer in padded leather gear and steel goggles with blood on his face after a bout

Picture two young men standing an arm's length apart, swords raised, feet planted. They aren't allowed to step back. They aren't allowed to flinch. Nobody's keeping score, there's no winner at the end and a doctor's waiting at the side of the room with needle and thread.


This is the Mensur, the strange ritual of German academic fencing. For about 200 years it was how students at universities across central Europe proved their nerve, and the scar it left on your cheek, the Schmiss, could open doors for the rest of your life. One 19th-century duellist who fought at least 13 bouts ended up with 137 scars on his head, face and neck. And here's the bit most people don't expect: it never really stopped.

Quick Answers

  • What's Mensur? A traditional, strictly regulated sword bout fought between members of German-speaking student fraternities, using sharp blades aimed only at the head.

  • Does anyone win a Mensur? No. There's no scoring. The point is to stand your ground and show composure under the blade.

  • What's a Schmiss? The facial scar left by a Mensur cut, long seen as a badge of honour and social standing.

  • Did the Nazis ban Mensur? Yes. The regime shut it down in the mid-1930s along with the student corporations, though secret bouts carried on.

  • Is Mensur still practised? Yes. Around 400 student fraternities still fence it, mostly in Germany, Austria and Switzerland.

What Actually Happens in a Mensur

Forget the swashbuckling you see in films. A Mensur is about as static as swordplay gets. The two fencers, called Paukanten, stand at a fixed distance and can't move their feet or dodge. Only cuts to the head are allowed and the bout stops when there's blood or when the agreed number of rounds is up.


The gear covers almost everything else. An 1884 description in the Saturday Review listed a padded leather vest down to the knees, a protected sword arm with a gauntlet, a wrist guard made of mail rings and iron spectacles with wire mesh instead of lenses. Today's versions add a throat guard and a nose guard to the goggles, and modern aprons are often lined with Kevlar.


Each fencer has a second who can step in and stop the fight, and there's always a doctor present. What's being judged isn't skill. It's whether you blink. A fencer who flinches or ducks can be marked down by his own fraternity and made to fight again.


Black and white photo of two students fencing a Mensur while a crowd of fraternity members watches
A Mensur in progress, with fraternity brothers looking on.

From Street Brawls to Ritual

The Mensur grew out of something much messier. Back in the 15th century students were allowed to carry swords for protection on the road, and unsurprisingly that led to a lot of fights, many of them fatal. By the 17th century universities were trying to tame it, introducing duels with referees, seconds and doctors in place of brawls in the street.


The real turning point came in the 1760s, when the University of Göttingen brought in a slashing weapon called the Göttinger Hieber. Cuts replaced thrusts and the death rate dropped sharply. Around the same time Frederick the Great banned civilians from duelling in the street or carrying swords in public, which left officers and students as more or less the only people still doing it legally.


By the middle of the 19th century the old way of picking a fight, by calling someone a "dummer Junge" (stupid boy), had been dropped. Instead the fraternities paired members up themselves and fencing became a condition of joining. That's the Mensur as it's still fought now: not a quarrel settled with steel but a test of character arranged by your own club.


Tycho Brahe Lost His Nose to a Student Duel

Long before the Mensur took its modern shape, student duels were already leaving marks on famous faces. In December 1566 a 20-year-old Danish student called Tycho Brahe got into an argument with his third cousin, Manderup Parsberg, while they were both at the University of Rostock. They settled it with swords and Tycho lost part of his nose.


He went on to become one of the greatest astronomers of his age, and he wore a metal prosthetic nose for the rest of his life. It's often said to have been gold or silver, though there's been plenty of argument about that over the years. The funny thing is that he and Parsberg later became friends.



The Schmiss: A Scar You Actually Wanted

If the Mensur was the test, the Schmiss was the certificate. A cut cheek told everyone you'd been to university, joined the right sort of fraternity and stood your ground. Some men collected them with real enthusiasm. One German student, Fritz Bacmeister, is thought to have fought around 100 bouts.



The scars weren't always left to heal neatly, either. Some fencers reopened their wounds to make them stand out more. And men who'd never been near a university were known to cut their own faces with razors to fake the look.


It's easy to see why. Otto von Bismarck reportedly sized up a man's courage by the number of scars on his face, and the old boys' network was very real. In 1928 former members of the Kösener corps association held about one in five senior posts in the Prussian civil service. A scar on the cheek wasn't just vanity. It was a CV.


Portrait of a man in a suit and bow tie with a visible Mensur scar on his cheek
For a certain class of German man, the Schmiss was as much a part of the outfit as the bow tie.

Sepia photo of students having head wounds bandaged after Mensur bouts
Patching up after the bouts. The doctor's work was part of the ritual.

Mark Twain Pulls Up a Chair

Foreign visitors were baffled and a bit thrilled by the whole thing. When Mark Twain toured Germany in the late 1870s he went to watch the corps students fence in Heidelberg, and he gave the Mensur several chapters in A Tramp Abroad, published in 1880. He was struck by how calmly the students took their wounds and how proudly they wore the results.


Jerome K. Jerome was far less impressed. In Three Men on the Bummel, his 1900 follow-up to Three Men in a Boat, he took a dim view of the German student duel. Between them the two writers did a lot to fix the image of the scarred German student in English-speaking minds.



Bans, a Kaiser and the Nazis

Strangely, the Mensur was one of the safer sports going. By some accounts it killed fewer people each year than cycling. But it wasn't harmless. In 1877 a student died after a bout at Göttingen and the authorities banned the practice, so the fraternities simply moved it into their basements.


That ban didn't last. In 1890 Kaiser Wilhelm II, a former corps student himself, looked into the Mensur and gave it his blessing, which effectively ended any official attempt to stop it. The late 19th and early 20th centuries were its golden age.


Seven fraternity members in caps gathered around a wooden chair in an early 20th century photo

Then came the Nazis. Hitler's problem wasn't really the swordplay. It was the corporations, which the regime saw as elitist and whose loyalty to each other got in the way of loyalty to the state. By the mid-1930s they'd been dissolved and the Mensur banned. Some carried on under cover. In Freiburg, a so-called comradeship named after the poet Hermann Löns kept fencing in secret, and more than 100 bouts were reportedly fought there during the war.


After 1945 the Allies banned it again, lumping it in with military-style organisations. The ban was lifted in 1953 and the fraternities came back, though the Mensur never quite recovered its old status.


The Scarred Men of the Third Reich

The irony is that so many of the regime's own men carried the Schmiss. The best-known face is probably Otto Skorzeny, the SS commando behind the 1943 Gran Sasso raid that freed Mussolini. His long cheek scar wasn't a war wound. He got it fencing as a student at the University of Vienna.


Otto Skorzeny in SS uniform showing the long duelling scar on his left cheek
Otto Skorzeny

He was far from the only one. Ernst Röhm, the brownshirt leader, had duelling scars. So did Rudolf Diels, the first head of the Gestapo from 1933 to 1934. Kurt Debus, who later ran launch operations for NASA, had one too, according to Rare Historical Photos. Between them they helped create the film cliché of the cold, scar-faced German officer that's still around today.



Did the Scar Actually Make Men More Attractive?

The old line was that a Schmiss made a student good husband material. In 2009 a team of psychologists at the University of Stirling decided to test something close to it. They showed 147 women pictures of men's faces, some digitally given scars and some not, and asked them to rate how attractive they were.


The scarred faces came out as more attractive for short-term relationships, with no real difference for long-term ones. The researchers suggested scars might signal masculinity and risk-taking, and the university's own press release pointed to German academic fencing as a case where men got scarred on purpose. So the 19th-century students may have been onto something, at least for a weekend.


Mensur Today

You might assume all this died out with the Kaiser. It didn't. Around 400 student corporations still fence the Mensur, in Germany, Austria and Switzerland but also in Belgium, Poland and the Baltic states, where the fraternities have their own long and colourful traditions (they once put on cross-dressing plays in Estonia, for a start).


Men in fraternity colours crowd around two fencers in full protective gear during a Mensur
Bouts are still fought in fraternity houses across the German-speaking world.

It isn't compulsory in every fraternity now and plenty of modern members never get a visible scar. Not everyone's convinced it should go on, either. In Switzerland it's widely seen as too violent and some Swiss corporations have swapped it for extreme hiking as a way of building character. Defenders like Albrecht Fehlig, a spokesman for the corps associations, argue it's tied to honour and the life of the fraternity house.


Three men in Mensur fencing gear standing in a dimly lit room
Modern Paukanten kitted out before a bout.

It can still go badly wrong. In February 2023 a Mensur at a fraternity in Erlangen ended with a student in hospital in a life-threatening condition. For a ritual built on proving you won't flinch, that's a reminder that the blades have always been real.


Five young men in early 20th century fencing gear posing for a group photo
Students in fencing kit, early 1900s.

Silver Mensur sword known as a Schläger with a basket hilt
The Schläger, the long, flexible blade used in the Mensur.

Sepia photo of a student having his head shaved and lathered before a bout

Suggested Reading

If you want to go deeper into the world of German student duelling, these two are a good place to start.


Dueling: The Cult of Honor in Fin-de-Siècle Germany by Kevin McAleer. A proper history of why educated German men kept fighting duels long after the rest of Europe had given up.


A Tramp Abroad by Mark Twain. Twain's travel book with his eyewitness chapters on the Heidelberg student duels.


As an Amazon Associate, Utterly Interesting earns from qualifying purchases.

You Might Also Like

Sources

 
 
bottom of page