Entirely a Matter for You: The Night Peter Cook Put the Thorpe Trial Judge in the Dock

Peter Cook spent most of the 1960s and 70s laughing at the people in charge. He co-wrote Beyond the Fringe, kept Private Eye afloat with his own money and made Derek and Clive records that still make people wince. But the sharpest ten minutes of his career came in June 1979, when he walked onto a West End stage dressed as a High Court judge and tore apart a real one.
The judge was Sir Joseph Cantley. A week earlier he'd presided over the trial of Jeremy Thorpe, the former Liberal leader accused of plotting to have his alleged ex-lover shot. Thorpe walked free. Cook thought the summing up had done most of the walking for him, and he said so in front of a packed theatre.
Quick Answers
What was Entirely a Matter for You? A sketch by Peter Cook parodying Mr Justice Cantley's summing up at the 1979 Jeremy Thorpe trial.
Where was it first performed? At Amnesty International's Secret Policeman's Ball, Her Majesty's Theatre, London, in late June 1979.
Why is it famous? It mocked a sitting judge days after a real verdict, ITV refused to broadcast it and it was released as a record anyway.
A Liberal Leader in the Dock at the Old Bailey
To get why the sketch hit so hard, you need the case it was sending up. Jeremy Thorpe became Liberal leader in 1967. When the prosecution opened its case in May 1979, it told the jury that his affair with a young man called Norman Scott in the early 1960s had become a nagging threat as Thorpe climbed the political ladder.

Scott wouldn't stay silent. In October 1975 an airline pilot called Andrew Newton drove him onto Exmoor, shot dead his Great Dane Rinka and then pointed the gun at Scott. It jammed. Newton was later jailed for two years for firearms offences and kept his mouth shut about who'd hired him until he got out.
By 1979 Thorpe was on trial for conspiracy and incitement to murder alongside three co-defendants: his friend David Holmes, carpet dealer John Le Mesurier and businessman George Deakin. The prosecution's star witness, former Liberal MP Peter Bessell, claimed Thorpe had once said getting rid of Scott would be "no worse than shooting a sick dog." The prosecution itself admitted the remark might have been ironic.
Thorpe chose not to give evidence. That turned out to matter a great deal less than you'd think.
The Summing Up That Did the Defence's Job
Mr Justice Cantley spent around 12 hours over two days summing up for the jury. On paper, a judge's summing up is neutral. In practice, Cantley's was anything but.
He described Thorpe as "a national figure with a very distinguished public record" and dismissed Bessell as a humbug. Scott got it worst. Cantley called him a fraud, a sponger, a whiner and a parasite, a list the Spectator's Roger Lewis says Scott will always be remembered by. Each time, the judge added that of course it was up to the jury to decide.

On 22 June 1979 the jury acquitted all four men. Plenty of people didn't like it, but a surprising number did. One later account in the Catholic Herald notes that Cantley became something of a national hero after the trial. Peter Cook wasn't one of his fans.
Private Eye Had Been Chasing Thorpe for Years
Cook wasn't some outsider taking a cheap shot. He'd been Private Eye's main financial backer since the early 1960s, and the magazine had been pushing the Thorpe story harder than anyone. As the London Review of Books puts it, allegations about Thorpe and a hit man had been cropping up since 1975, and nowhere more often than in the Eye.
The Eye's Auberon Waugh went further still. At editor Richard Ingrams' suggestion he stood against Thorpe in North Devon at the May 1979 general election as the candidate for the Dog Lovers' Party, in honour of poor Rinka. His election address was so pointed that the Court of Appeal ruled it posed a serious risk of prejudice to the upcoming trial, and Thorpe got an injunction against it. The banned manifesto included the line "Rinka is not forgotten. Rinka lives."
Waugh polled a grand total of 79 votes. Thorpe still lost, though. Waugh later liked to point out that a Liberal majority of 6,721 became a Conservative majority of 8,473. He sat through the trial too, and turned it into a book, The Last Word, which the LRB reviewed under the heading Beyond Discussion.
So when the verdict came in, the Private Eye crowd were primed. Cook just happened to have the biggest stage.
Written in a Rush for the Secret Policeman's Ball
The Secret Policeman's Ball was Amnesty International's fundraising comedy show. In 1979 it ran for four nights at Her Majesty's Theatre from 27 June, just five days after Thorpe was cleared. John Cleese, Rowan Atkinson, Billy Connolly and most of Monty Python were on the bill.

The opening night got lukewarm reviews. Cook, who'd been at the Private Eye office helping with the Thorpe coverage, decided the show needed something with teeth. He wrote a parody of Cantley's summing up, ran the phrasing past Michael Palin and Billy Connolly and debuted it on the second night.
It opened with the judge asking whether the jury had brought a toothbrush, a dig at a real moment in the trial when Cantley had threatened a journalist who'd displeased him. The audience got the reference instantly. By the time it finished, roughly ten minutes later, the critics who'd been lukewarm the day before were raving.
How the Joke Actually Worked
The genius of the sketch was that Cook barely had to exaggerate. Judges summing up routinely tell juries that how they weigh the evidence is "entirely a matter for you." Cantley had said versions of it while making his own views perfectly plain. Cook simply turned the volume up.
His judge pours scorn on every prosecution witness in increasingly unhinged terms, then reminds the jury, with a straight face, that believing them is entirely up to them. As the Australian legal site Justinian dryly put it, the title was really judgespeak for the judge's own opinion. The big closer tells the jury to go away and consider their verdict of not guilty, adding "You are now to retire, as indeed should I".
Years later a legal trade piece looking back at the sketch noted that it painted High Court judges as privileged, prejudiced and patronising. It also admitted that at the time it wasn't entirely wide of the mark. Coming from the legal press, that's quite a concession.
Too Hot for ITV, Fine for Virgin Records
When ITV broadcast highlights of the Ball in December 1979, the Thorpe sketch was missing. ITV's film buyer Leslie Halliwell reportedly felt it was an unfair joke at an innocent man's expense and "not suitable for television." It survived in the cinema version of the show and on the live album, so the cut didn't do much good.
Virgin Records then put the live recording out as a 12-inch single called Here Comes the Judge. Cook's first idea for the B-side was a dub reggae version of the sketch, which is about as Peter Cook as it gets. Virgin wanted proper new material, so he went into Berwick Street Studios in Soho with producer John Lloyd and recorded three more:
Well-Hung Jury, a Derek and Clive-style exchange between two jurors that's as rude as the title suggests.
Thanksgiving, a clergyman giving thanks for the verdict. Libel worries forced Cook to switch the target to the Yorkshire Ripper, who was still at large at the time.
Rad Job, in which a twitchy politician hires a man in very vague terms to "repair" a radiator by shooting it through the head.
The promotion was even cheekier. The film was launched with a screening at the National Liberal Club, of all places. The single was plugged with a photo shoot of Cook in his judge's wig standing next to the real Norman Scott.
Who Came Out of It Best?
Thorpe was acquitted but never really recovered. His career was finished and the questions he'd chosen not to answer in court followed him until his death in 2014. Cantley stayed on the bench and died in 1993, best remembered, fairly or not, as the judge Peter Cook made a laughing stock.
Norman Scott, the man the court had written off, outlived nearly all of them. In 2022 he finally published his own account, An Accidental Icon. The Spectator's review argued the case was one of the worst miscarriages of justice of modern times, driven by class bias, homophobia and establishment cover-up. It's a familiar pattern in British scandals, from Lord Boothby and Ronnie Kray to the aristocratic friends who closed ranks around Lord Lucan.
Peter Cook, born on 17 November 1937, died in January 1995 at just 57. People often say he wasted his talent in later life. Maybe. But for one week in 1979 he did exactly what satire is supposed to do. He watched the powerful look after their own and then he stood up in public and laughed at them until everyone else did too. Whether you think that makes him a genius is, of course, entirely a matter for you.
Suggested Reading
Want to dig deeper into Cook and the Thorpe affair? These are worth a look.
Peter Cook: A Biography by Harry Thompson. The definitive life of Cook, from Cambridge Footlights to his last years in Hampstead, written by the producer of Have I Got News for You.
A Very English Scandal by John Preston. The gripping account of the Thorpe affair that became the BBC drama with Hugh Grant and Ben Whishaw.
An Accidental Icon by Norman Scott. Scott's own memoir, finally giving his side of a story that everyone else told for him.
As an Amazon Associate, Utterly Interesting earns from qualifying purchases.
You Might Also Like
Sources
Entirely A Matter For You, Tim Worthington
Entirely a matter for you, Justinian
Entirely a matter for you (archive), Justinian
The bar educating the judge, Law.com International
Norman Scott has the last word on a very English scandal, The Spectator
The Thorpe affair (The Advocate, July 2022), The Advocate
Lover was threat, so Thorpe plotted murder (Press, 11 May 1979), Papers Past
Thorpe's black cloud (Press, 12 May 1979), Papers Past
Jury out in Thorpe case after judge slates witnesses (Press, 21 June 1979), PrideNZ
The Thorpe affair and the establishment, Catholic Herald
Woof, woof, London Review of Books
In contempt (5 May 1979), The Spectator Archive
Auberon Waugh and the Dog Lovers' Party, The Spectator Australia
A celebration of Auberon Waugh, The Daily Telegraph
Another voice (18 February 1989), The Spectator Archive
Beyond Discussion, London Review of Books





















































































