The Columbine Mine Massacre: When Colorado Police Opened Fire on Striking Miners

S
ay "Columbine" to most people and they'll think of 1999. But 72 years earlier, on a freezing November morning in a Colorado company town with the painfully ironic name of Serene, state police shot into a crowd of around 500 striking coal miners, wives and kids. Six men died. Dozens more were hurt.
It's sometimes called the first Columbine massacre, and it's one of the worst episodes in America's long, bloody fight between miners and the companies that owned them. Yet the graves of the dead went unmarked for 61 years and the spot where they fell is now buried under a landfill. Here's the story.
Quick Answers
What was it? The shooting of striking coal miners by Colorado state police at the Columbine Mine.
When did it happen? At dawn on Monday 21 November 1927.
Where? Serene, a company town about 30 miles north of Denver, owned by the Rocky Mountain Fuel Company.
How many died? Six miners were killed and somewhere between 20 and 60 people were wounded, depending on whose count you trust.
Was anyone punished? No. A coroner's inquest cleared the police.
A Strike That Started With Sacco and Vanzetti
Colorado's coal fields were already soaked in blood by 1927. The Ludlow Massacre of 1914 had left women and children dead in a burning tent colony, and in the years that followed the big mine owners had pretty much stamped out the unions. Wages had stalled. Conditions had got worse. Colorado's mines had the highest death rate in the country, workers were often paid in company scrip and plenty of miners were convinced the scales weighing their coal were rigged.

The spark came from somewhere unexpected. In August 1927 the Industrial Workers of the World, better known as the Wobblies, called a nationwide walkout in protest at the coming executions of Italian anarchists Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti. The response in Colorado's southern coal fields was huge, and the union's local organiser, a former clergyman called A.S. Embree who'd survived the infamous Bisbee Deportation in Arizona, realised the miners were ready for something bigger.
On 18 October 1927 the IWW launched a statewide coal strike. By the end of that month the Zinn Education Project puts the number of strikers at more than 8,000, and nearly every coal mine in Colorado had ground to a halt. It was the only time miners in all of the state's coal districts walked out together, and as the Verso encyclopedia of US labour history points out, it turned out to be the Wobblies' last mass strike.
Flaming Milka and the Women Who Ran the Strike
The authorities went after the strike leaders hard, locking up organisers for vagrancy or illegal picketing whenever they could get hold of them. So the women stepped in.

The most famous was Amelia Milka Sablich, the 19-year-old daughter of a Croatian miner from Trinidad, Colorado. She wore bright red, wasn't afraid to square up to men twice her size and led hundreds of hardened miners on picket lines. Newspapers dubbed her Flaming Milka. Early in the strike she ended up in hospital after being trampled by a sheriff's horse on a picket line near Ludlow, and she spent around five weeks behind bars over at least two spells. At one point she was offered her freedom if she promised to stop going to strike meetings. She turned it down.
After the massacre she and Embree went on a national fundraising tour, and the Shoe Leather History Project has a great piece on her visit to Hartford, Connecticut, in January 1928. Their report on New York's WEVD radio station is thought to have been the station's first ever labour broadcast.
The Last Mine Still Digging
Up north, one big mine refused to close. The Columbine sat in Serene, a company town on rolling hills near Lafayette and Erie, and it was owned by the Rocky Mountain Fuel Company, which along with the Rockefeller-controlled Colorado Fuel and Iron dominated the state's coal industry. With the help of about 150 strikebreakers housed inside the fence, it kept turning out coal, slowly, while every other mine in the northern field sat idle.
That made it the obvious target. For two weeks strikers turned up at the Columbine gates most mornings for rallies, often marching in with American flags and singing. Things were surprisingly friendly at first. Josephine Roche, a progressive social worker who'd inherited her late father's shares in the company that January, reportedly had coffee and doughnuts sent out to the picketers.
Then the state got involved. Governor Billy Adams had scrapped Colorado's state police as a campaign promise, but now he brought them back and put Louis Scherf in charge. Scherf had been second in command during the 1922 strike-breaking operation under a commander who'd led the anti-union forces at Ludlow. On 5 November his men waded into about 500 miners at Berwind Canyon with clubs and fists. Military aircraft made mock dive-bombing runs over strike rallies. And from 16 November the Columbine was fortified with machine guns and electrified barbed wire.

What Happened at the Columbine Gate on 21 November 1927
On Sunday 20 November more than a thousand people packed a strike rally in Boulder. Overnight, police reinforcements were rushed to Serene.
Before dawn the next morning, around 500 miners arrived at the Columbine's north gate. Some had brought their wives and children. They carried three American flags. Two Weld County deputies met them at the outer gate and told them to clear off, then drove back through the inner gate. The strikers followed.
Waiting for them was a squad of around 20 state police in plain clothes, armed with automatic pistols, rifles, riot guns and tear gas, with rifle-carrying mine guards backing them up from the top of the mine dump. When Scherf yelled out asking who their leaders were, the crowd shouted back that they were all leaders.
IWW organiser Adam Bell climbed up to the gate and was clubbed by police, pulled over and beaten unconscious. A flagpole snapped. Tear gas was fired. Elizabeth Beranek, a mother of 16, was bruised trying to shield Bell from the blows. The furious crowd broke the padlock and forced the gate open.
Scherf fired two shots from his .45 over the strikers' heads. His men then fired straight into the crowd. As the miners scattered in the half light, men dropped where they stood. Scherf himself later put it bluntly, according to the Rebel Graphics account of the massacre: "We knocked them down as fast as they came over the gate."
The Six Men Who Died
The six miners killed at the Columbine were:
John Eastenes, 34, of Lafayette, a father of six, who was killed instantly
Nick Spanudakhis, 34, of Lafayette, who died within minutes
Frank Kovich, of Erie, who died in hospital hours later
Rene Jacques, 26, of Louisville, who also died in hospital that day
Jerry Davis, just 21, who'd been carrying one of the flags and died in hospital later that day
Mike Vidovich, 35, of Erie, who held on for a week before dying of his wounds
The flag Jerry Davis had been carrying was later found with 17 bullet holes in it. As for the wounded, most accounts settle on around 20 but some put the real figure nearer 60, with at least two women badly hurt. The exact number is still argued about today.

The Cover Story and the Machine Gun Question
Police claimed the miners had snipers and nitroglycerin bombs. Not a single officer was shot, and the so-called bomb later turned out to contain tear gas. A local marshal who'd been in the crowd said he knew for certain the men weren't armed, and one of the Weld County deputies told the inquest he hadn't heard a single shot from the strikers.
The machine guns are where things get murkier. Governor Adams insisted they'd been put into storage at his personal request. Miners said they were fired on from the mine's tipple and from a truck-mounted gun near the water tank. Nobody's ever settled it.
The official verdict didn't take long. The Boulder coroner said he didn't need an inquest to know how the men died and simply wrote that they'd suffered gunshot wounds in a riot. The inquest found no wrongdoing by the police. Instead, strike leaders were locked up and blamed for the deaths.
Funerals, Tanks and Burning Newspapers
The towns around the mine were devastated. Eastenes's funeral packed out Lafayette's Union Theatre. About 3,000 people turned out for Spanudakhis, who was buried on Thanksgiving Day, and a crowd of around 5,000 came for Davis and Kovich the following day. Jacques was laid to rest in his family's plot in Louisville. Angry Lafayette residents burned stacks of newspapers in the street over what they saw as lies about the shooting.
The state's response was to double down. The National Guard rolled in with tanks and bombers, the Columbine's fence was electrified to 420 volts and so-called citizens' committees wrecked two union halls. In early 1928 police shot into a crowd outside the IWW hall in Walsenburg, killing Wobbly Clemente Chavez and 16-year-old bystander Celestino Martinez. A jury found the police had shown a total disregard for human life. Again, nobody was charged.

The strike wound down in early 1928. But it wasn't a total loss. As the Industrial Worker's history of the strike notes, the miners went back having won a dollar-a-day raise, the only wage increases anywhere in US coal mining between 1928 and 1930.
Josephine Roche's Surprising U-Turn
The strangest twist belongs to the woman who owned the mine. Roche was horrified by the killings, and Time magazine later described how bitter it was for a lifelong social worker to see six miners die within sight of her company's tipple. She went on to take control of Rocky Mountain Fuel, and within a year of the shooting she'd done something unheard of in Colorado.
On 16 August 1928 she signed a contract with the United Mine Workers of America, the first union contract the UMWA had ever won in the state. Her miners got seven dollars a day, and she hired John Lawson, a veteran of the 1914 Ludlow strike, as vice president. When the Depression hit, her workers voted to lend half their wages back to the company for three months to keep it afloat. Roche went on to serve in Franklin D. Roosevelt's administration, though Rocky Mountain Fuel finally folded in 1944.

Not everyone sees her as a hero, mind you. Historian Leigh Campbell-Hale argues the UMWA had done nothing for the strike except denounce it, and that the contract handed union boss John L. Lewis a lifeline at his lowest moment. In a 1944 memo, Roche herself pointed the finger at Jesse Welborn, the Rockefellers' man in Colorado, as the person mainly responsible for sending in the state police.
Why Has Everyone Forgotten the Columbine?
Ludlow gets the monuments, the books and the school lessons. The Columbine got almost nothing. Campbell-Hale's piece for the US working-class history association LAWCHA blames textbooks that wrongly claim the IWW was finished by the 1920s, plus a convenient habit among union leaders, Roche and even surviving Wobblies of talking up Ludlow while staying vague about their own part in what happened at Serene.
It took until 1989, as part of Lafayette's centennial, for IWW members and local historians to pay for a headstone over the graves of the five miners buried in Lafayette cemetery. A historical marker now stands on State Highway 7, about a mile west of Interstate 25.
The massacre site itself has had a grimmer fate. It's buried under a landfill, and the landscaped slope of that rubbish heap now serves as open space for a housing estate built around a golf course in Erie. Most of the people living there probably have no idea six men were gunned down just over the hill.
If you're interested in other moments when ordinary workers paid the price for corporate indifference, have a look at the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire or the strange death of Karen Silkwood. And for a much older slice of Colorado's dark side, there's always Alfred Packer, the Colorado cannibal.
Suggested Reading
Want to know more about Colorado's coal wars? These are well worth a look.
Remembering Ludlow but Forgetting the Columbine by Leigh Campbell-Hale. The only full-length book on the 1927 strike and massacre, and a sharp look at why one tragedy got remembered and the other didn't.
Killing for Coal: America's Deadliest Labor War by Thomas G. Andrews. A prize-winning history of the Colorado coal fields that explains how things got so violent in the first place.
Blood Passion: The Ludlow Massacre and Class War in the American West by Scott Martelle. A gripping account of Ludlow, the massacre that cast such a long shadow over everything that happened at the Columbine.
As an Amazon Associate, Utterly Interesting earns from qualifying purchases.
You Might Also Like
Sources
Marked, Unmarked, Remembered: Remembering Ludlow, Forgetting Columbine, Labor and Working-Class History Association
The Columbine Mine Massacre, Rebel Graphics
Colorado and the IWW, Part III: The Colorado Coal Strike of 1927, Industrial Worker
Nov. 21, 1927: Columbine Mine Massacre, Zinn Education Project
Colorado Coal Mine Workers' Strike of 1927-1928, Verso Books
The Woman in Red, Shoe Leather History Project
This Day in Labor History: November 21, 1927, Lawyers, Guns & Money
This Day in Labor History: August 16, 1928, Lawyers, Guns & Money
Josephine Roche, Colorado Women's Hall of Fame via Google Arts & Culture
The Strike of 1927, The Colorado Fuel and Iron Company project
Nick Spanudakhis memorial, Find a Grave





















































































