top of page

The Model, Series No. 1: Albert Arthur Allen's Banned Flapper Nudes of 1925

11 minutes ago
7 min read
Seven bobbed-haired nude models in a line with hands on each other's shoulders, under the title The Model, Series No. 1: Albert Arthur Allen's Banned Flapper Nudes of 1925

In 1925 a photographer working out of Oakland, California put together a portfolio of 15 nude photographs, sold it to subscribers by post and promptly landed himself in more trouble with the federal government. His name was Albert Arthur Allen and he genuinely believed he was doing women a favour.


He wasn't a seedy back-room operator, or at least he didn't think he was. He was a rich kid from Massachusetts with big ideas about art, democracy and the female body. The trouble was that the US Post Office saw things very differently.

Quick Answers

  • Who was Albert Arthur Allen? An American photographer (1886 to 1962) based in Oakland, best known for nude studies of flapper-era women.

  • What's The Model, Series No. 1? A 1925 portfolio of 15 silver prints of nude women, generally seen as his best and most sought-after work.

  • Why did he get into legal trouble? Mailing nude photos across state lines broke the federal Comstock laws, and he was indicted more than once.

  • What's it worth now? Complete sets turn up at auction every few years, with the record standing at $8,400.

A Rich Kid With a Camera

Allen was born on 8 May 1886 near Grafton, Massachusetts. His family had made its money in shipbuilding and, handily for a man with expensive hobbies, his parents kept bankrolling him well into the 1920s.


Portrait photograph of Oakland photographer Albert Arthur Allen in an open-necked white shirt
Albert Arthur Allen

At 21 he headed west to California and spent a few years studying art. In 1916 he opened the Allen Art Studio in Oakland and set about solving what he called the scientific problems of photography. Solving them wasn't cheap. Salon reported that he burned through $63,000 on experiments, which works out at around $2 million in today's money.


His early work leaned towards the soft, painterly Pictorialist style that was fashionable at the time, the same dreamy look you'll find in Arthur Kales' soft-focus California photographs. His first nudes were posed out of doors along the Pacific coast and among the trees. By around 1919 he'd moved indoors and was shooting models against a plain black backdrop.


Equality Through Nudity

Allen insisted his pictures weren't meant to titillate anyone. He saw them as art with a social purpose, and he once wrote that "to see womankind entirely nude would place all women on equality". In his view, strip away the expensive clothes and every woman would be judged on her own mental and physical charm rather than her wardrobe.


Line of nude flappers with their arms raised in a V, dancing in Albert Arthur Allen's 1925 portfolio The Model, Series No. 1
From Albert Arthur Allen's 1925 portfolio The Model, Series No. 1

He also held some odd theories to go with it. He came up with his own word, "sexine", and wrote quasi-scientific texts linking body types to personality. Photo historian Daile Kaplan, who's written more about Allen than anyone, reckons the term described a woman who wasn't a virgin but hadn't had children either.


He also had firm views on what made a good model. He apparently favoured "red-blooded American good looks" and claimed his models trained for months to get their poses right.


What Made His Nudes So Different

Nude photography wasn't new in the 1920s. Plenty of photographers were shooting it, from E. J. Bellocq in the brothels of Storyville to the polite "art study" postcards sold across Europe. What set Allen apart was that he didn't airbrush his models. His prints showed pubic hair, which was close to unheard of in commercial nudes of the period and exactly the sort of detail that got censors reaching for their pens.



The women themselves are very much of their moment. Almost all of them wear bobbed hair with neat art deco waves, the look of the same flapper generation that gave us women like Rebecca Bradley, the Texas Flapper Bandit. That haircut is half the reason these photos look so striking today. Nothing dates a nude like a 1920s hairdo.


Bobbed-haired nude models posing on and around stone blocks, one pointing, in a 1925 Albert Arthur Allen photograph
Allen's models almost all wore the fashionable bob of the 1920s

Over the course of the decade his settings got more theatrical. Models posed at pianos, in baths and inside mock harem tents. One series called "Sex Appeal" showed a woman in a drop-waist dress, then in her underwear, then in nothing but stockings and a garter belt. Around 1926 he even did a parody of Rudolph Valentino's The Sheik, complete with a middle-aged Valentino lookalike and a naked woman holding a revolver. It's the same staged, slightly surreal brand of nudity that Salvador Dalí would take to the 1939 World's Fair with his Dream of Venus pavilion.



Inside The Model, Series No. 1

The 1925 portfolio is the one collectors chase. It's sometimes called "The Models" online, but auction houses list it as The Model, Series No. 1. A complete set has 15 original silver prints, each roughly 16.5 by 24 centimetres.


It's a big group production. Allen's 1925 work leaned heavily on choreographed tableaux, with nude women dancing, posing, staging mock archery and even running through military-style drills. When Kaplan looked at the scale of the stage and the size of the backdrop, she suspected he'd hired a theatre rather than using his own studio.


A nude dancer leaping in the centre while four women sit and recline around her, from The Model, Series No. 1
A complete set of the portfolio runs to 15 silver prints

Kaplan, who ran the photographs department at Swann Auction Galleries in New York, rated it Allen's most successful portfolio. She also described him as "a grandiose figure with larger-than-life ambitions", which seems about right for a man who thought nude photos could fix inequality.


Allen never numbered his editions or kept proper sales records, so nobody knows how many sets he sold. Kaplan has even suggested he may have been advised to destroy his paperwork. Complete copies only surface every few years. Swann sold one for $8,400 in October 2007, another went for $3,600 in 2009 and a third was estimated at $4,000 to $6,000 when it came up in 2018, consigned by a woman whose great-grandfather had bought it.



Allen vs the Post Office

Here's the catch. Taking nude photos in 1920s California was perfectly legal. Posting them wasn't. Under the Comstock laws, first passed in 1873, sending anything deemed obscene through the US mail was a federal crime, and visible pubic hair was more than enough to qualify.


Allen's whole business ran on mail order. He advertised in newspapers and art publications, and Kaplan says his ads also turned up in the kind of printed matter found in barber shops and men's clubs. Subscribers paid and the portfolios arrived by post.


Nude models forming an arch with their arms over a woman sitting on the floor, in Albert Arthur Allen's 1925 portfolio
Photos like this were legal to take but illegal to post across state lines

It didn't take long for the authorities to notice. He was indicted in 1924 for mailing obscene material across state lines, then indicted again in 1925 for shipping it through American Express. The cases dragged on for years and, by Kaplan's account, were costly and time-consuming. San Francisco's moral campaigners didn't help either, and at one point he was hauled in front of a judge over the photos.


Fire, a Crash and a Nudie Film

If the legal fight wasn't bad enough, the rest of the decade was brutal. In 1923 his motorcycle hit a streetcar and crushed his right leg. His hip ended up fused and he spent the rest of his life walking bent over or on crutches. He kept working regardless.



In 1925 a fire destroyed his studio, which by then had been renamed the Allen Institute of Fine and Applied Art. Allen rebuilt and relaunched as the Classic Motion Picture Corporation, hoping to make nude films. Accounts of how long it lasted vary, but it ended in bankruptcy before the decade was out.


One film did make it out, though. Forbidden Daughters is a 13-minute silent short from 1927 about a woman who travels to Africa to find her missing husband and stumbles onto a lost tribe of mostly naked women. It's thought to be the only film Allen directed, and it survives today as an early example of the American "nudie" short.



Fading Into Obscurity

By the 1930s Allen's moment had passed. His next-to-last series, Premiere Nudes 1930, showed eight nude women posed as a group with one in the foreground wearing only shoes. In 1936 he was working as a photographer for the Elysium Foundation, a California nudist organisation. After that the trail goes cold.


He died on 25 January 1962 in Hayward, California, aged 75, leaving a son named Frederick. Even the basic facts of his life are slippery. Salon noted that the biography he wrote about himself contained a fair bit of fiction.


Ring of nude models holding hands and dancing around a column in a 1925 tableau by Albert Arthur Allen
Allen's work wasn't exhibited commercially until 1979

Recognition came long after he was gone. His first commercial exhibition was held in 1979, 17 years after his death, and a retrospective followed in 1992. In 2001 Twin Palms published Premiere Nudes, a hefty collection of his work with an introduction by Kaplan. Today his prints sit in museum collections including the Los Angeles County Museum of Art, which is quite the turnaround for a man the Post Office once treated as a smut peddler.

Suggested Reading

Want to see more of Allen's work or find out how America policed its morals back then? These are worth a look.


Albert Arthur Allen: Premiere Nudes by Daile Kaplan. The definitive collection of Allen's photographs, with Kaplan's introduction pulling together what little is known about the man.


Lust on Trial: Censorship and the Rise of American Obscenity in the Age of Anthony Comstock by Amy Werbel. A lively history of the man behind the laws that made Allen's mail-order business a federal crime.


As an Amazon Associate, Utterly Interesting earns from qualifying purchases.

You Might Also Like

Sources

 
 
bottom of page