top of page

The Violent Life and Even More Violent Death of James "Whitey" Bulger

Sep 3, 2023
12 min read

Updated: Oct 30

Composite image of Boston gangster James Whitey Bulger as an older man in a cap alongside a younger photo of him

For the best part of two decades, James "Whitey" Bulger ran Boston's underworld while the FBI looked the other way. He extorted, smuggled, dealt and killed. All the while, his handler at the Bureau kept tipping him off. When the law finally came for him, he vanished for 16 years. And when he was eventually caught, convicted and locked away, the American prison system managed to deliver an 89-year-old man in a wheelchair straight into the hands of people who wanted him dead.


On 30 October 2018, within hours of arriving at a West Virginia penitentiary, Bulger was beaten to death. Here's how a Southie kid became America's most wanted man, and how his story ended the way so many of his victims' did.

Quick Answers

  • Who was Whitey Bulger? An Irish-American gangster who led Boston's Winter Hill Gang and secretly worked as an FBI informant from 1975.

  • How long was he on the run? Sixteen years, from late 1994 until his arrest in Santa Monica on 22 June 2011.

  • How did he die? He was beaten to death at USP Hazelton in West Virginia on 30 October 2018, aged 89, just hours after being transferred there.

  • Who killed him? Former Mafia hitman Fotios "Freddy" Geas, with Paul DeCologero involved and Sean McKinnon acting as lookout.

A Southie Kid Who Hated His Nickname

James Joseph Bulger Jr was born on 3 September 1929 and grew up in South Boston, the tight-knit, fiercely Irish neighbourhood everyone calls Southie. He was the second of six kids. His dad had lost an arm in an industrial accident, money was always short and the family ended up in the Old Harbor housing project.


Black and white photo of a smiling young Jimmy Bulger aged about 14 holding a glass bottle
Jimmy Bulger at 14 years of age.

The nickname came from his shock of white-blond hair. He hated it. Friends and family called him Jimmy, and anyone who called him Whitey to his face usually came to regret it.


He was arrested for the first time at 14, and the charges piled up from there: larceny, assault, robbery. By his late teens he'd done a stretch in a juvenile reformatory, and Boston's police knew exactly who he was.


Front and side mugshot of a teenage Whitey Bulger with a Boston police booking number
17-year-old Bulger in a 1947 mugshot.

Air Force, Bank Jobs and the CIA's LSD Tests

In 1948, aged 18, Bulger joined the US Air Force. It didn't straighten him out. He was locked in the stockade for assaults at Smoky Hill Air Force Base in Kansas and arrested for going AWOL in 1950, yet somehow walked away in 1952 with an honourable discharge.


Back in Boston he moved up from petty theft to armed robbery and hijacking lorries. In 1956 he was convicted of bank robbery and handed a federal sentence that took him through some of America's toughest prisons, including Atlanta, Leavenworth and, for a short spell, Alcatraz.


Black and white photo of a young Whitey Bulger in a vest and dark trousers standing beside a garage door

It was in Atlanta that things got properly strange. Bulger and other inmates were offered time off their sentences to take part in what they were told was medical research into a cure for schizophrenia. In reality it was linked to the CIA's MK-Ultra mind control programme. Over roughly 15 months, Bulger was dosed with LSD more than 50 times.


He later wrote about violent nightmares and hallucinations that went on for years. He said he woke up roughly every hour and sometimes slept with the lights on. He even remembered technicians asking him whether he'd ever kill anyone. Years after his trial, juror Janet Uhlar said she regretted convicting him of murder because nobody had told the jury about the LSD. Her words were blunt: "Had I known, I would have absolutely held off on the murder charges."


It's a theory rather than an excuse. Plenty of people with no experience of LSD at all have committed murder. But it's one of the oddest footnotes in the history of American organised crime, and it sits alongside other unsettling 1950s LSD stories, like Cary Grant's experiments with the drug.


Winter Hill and the Southie Empire

Bulger was released in 1965 and went straight back to Southie. Boston's underworld at the time was split along ethnic lines, with the Italian-American Patriarca family holding the North End and a collection of Irish gangs scrapping over everything else.


Black and white Boston police mugshot of a young Whitey Bulger dated March 1953
A mugshot of Whitey Bulger in 1953.

Through the 1970s he climbed into the leadership of the Winter Hill Gang, named after the Somerville neighbourhood where it started. He ran loan sharking, bookmaking and protection rackets. Bars, liquor shops and bookies paid him to keep operating, and anyone who refused found out what Bulger meant by protection.


He loved to tell people he kept drugs out of Southie. The opposite was true. Dealers paid him a cut to work his turf, and the neighbourhood that saw him as its tough-guy guardian was flooded with cocaine and heroin on his watch.


Surveillance photo of Whitey Bulger in a baseball cap walking outdoors with his right-hand man Kevin Weeks
This undated surveillance photo shows James "Whitey" Bulger, left, walking with his former right-hand man, Kevin Weeks.


The FBI's Favourite Gangster

In 1975, Bulger signed up as an FBI informant. His handler was Special Agent John Connolly, another Southie boy who'd grown up idolising the older Bulger. The Bureau's top priority was taking down the Mafia, and Bulger had plenty to say about his Italian rivals.


The deal suited everyone except the people of Boston. The FBI got the intelligence it needed to gut the Patriarca family's local operation. Bulger and his partner Stephen "The Rifleman" Flemmi, who was also an informant, got something far more valuable: a Bureau that leaked him the names of anyone talking to investigators and steered prosecutors away from his own crimes.


Black and white mugshot of Stephen Flemmi as a young man looking straight at the camera
Stephen Flemmi in 1965.

Bulger's younger brother Billy, meanwhile, was one of the most powerful politicians in Massachusetts, serving as president of the state Senate from 1978 to 1996. One brother made the laws in Boston while the other broke them with the FBI's blessing. You couldn't write it.


The FBI has had other agents go spectacularly bad, of course. Robert Hanssen sold secrets to Moscow for two decades. But Connolly's corruption got people killed on American streets.


The Murders Even Boston Couldn't Ignore

Bulger's protection from the FBI meant that anyone who threatened to talk was in mortal danger. Some of the killings tied to him include:


  • Roger Wheeler, the Oklahoma businessman who owned World Jai Alai. He'd started to suspect the gang was skimming from his company and was shot dead in his car at a Tulsa country club in 1981.

  • Brian Halloran and Michael Donahue, gunned down on the Boston waterfront in 1982. Halloran had been talking to the FBI, and word got back to Bulger. Donahue was simply giving him a lift home.

  • John Callahan, the former World Jai Alai president, murdered in 1982 after Connolly warned Bulger and Flemmi that he was about to implicate them. His body turned up in the boot of a Cadillac at Miami airport.

  • Debra Davis, Flemmi's 26-year-old girlfriend, strangled in 1981. Her remains weren't found until 2000.


Former FBI agent John Connolly in a red prison jumpsuit standing in a courtroom with his hands clasped
Former FBI Special Agent John Connolly.

Most of those bodies stayed hidden for decades. Kevin Weeks, Bulger's right-hand man, was arrested in 1999 and eventually agreed to cooperate. In 2000 he led investigators to the graves. Paul McGonagle, allegedly killed by Bulger in 1974, and Debra Davis were found buried at Tenean Beach in Dorchester. Arthur "Bucky" Barrett, Deborah Hussey and John McIntyre were dug up near Florian Hall, a few miles away.


Bulger's reach went beyond Boston, too. In 1984 his crew helped load a shipment of around seven tonnes of guns and ammunition for the IRA onto a trawler out of Gloucester, Massachusetts. The weapons were transferred at sea to the Irish boat Marita Ann, which the Irish Navy seized off the coast of Kerry. Bulger wasn't the only Irish-American gangster with a long reach, as the strange story of Frank Sheeran, the Irishman, shows.


Sixteen Years on the Run

Before the walls closed in, Bulger pulled off one of his cheekiest stunts. In the summer of 1991, a $14.3 million Mass Millions ticket was sold at the South Boston Liquor Mart, a shop Bulger's crew ran. The winner was Michael Linskey, but Bulger and two associates paid him cash for a half share, and Bulger's name went on the claim. It handed him about $119,000 a year in clean, state-paid income. It didn't last. When he went on the run, federal prosecutors went after the remaining lottery money, and the Bulger family never saw a penny of it.


By the early 1990s a new generation of state and federal investigators, who didn't answer to Connolly, were closing in. In late 1994, Connolly tipped off Bulger, Flemmi and Mafia boss Francis "Cadillac Frank" Salemme that indictments were coming. Flemmi and Salemme were arrested. Bulger was already gone.


He'd been preparing for years, stashing cash and setting up false identities. Some of it ended up in Britain. FBI files point to a safe deposit box in Birmingham, believed to hold cash, jewellery and a fake passport, with a second box reportedly in London. The Bureau chased reported sightings of him in the UK in the early 1990s, and the exact location of the Birmingham box has never been made public.


After a spell travelling with long-term girlfriend Catherine Greig, he settled in Santa Monica, California, where the pair lived as Charlie and Carol Gasko in a rent-controlled flat at the Princess Eugenia apartments, a few streets from the beach.


To the neighbours, Charlie was a grumpy retiree who wore a hat and dark glasses, read history books and walked along the seafront. Meanwhile his face sat on the FBI's Ten Most Wanted list, right near the top alongside Osama bin Laden, with a $2 million reward on his head.



How a Stray Cat and a Former Miss Iceland Brought Him Down

After years of getting nowhere, the FBI changed tack in June 2011. Rather than hunt Bulger, they hunted Greig. They ran ads during daytime TV shows aimed at women, focusing on her love of cosmetic dentistry, beauty salons and animals.


One of the viewers was Anna Bjornsdottir, an actress and model who'd been Miss Iceland in 1974 and who'd spent time in Santa Monica. She recognised the couple she'd chatted to while they fed a stray cat outside their building. Bulger rarely left the flat, but he liked that cat. Bjornsdottir called the FBI, and she later collected the full $2 million reward.


On 22 June 2011, agents lured Bulger out of the flat by having the building manager tell him someone had broken into his storage locker. He walked straight into an arrest team. Inside the apartment they found $822,000 in cash hidden in the walls and around 30 guns.


FBI agent Scott Garriola beside an elderly Whitey Bulger in a white hat at the moment of his 2011 arrest in Santa Monica
FBI Agent Scott Garriola captures Whitey Bulger in 2011 at the fugitive's California hideaway.

The Trial

Bulger's trial in Boston opened in June 2013. He was charged with 32 counts, including involvement in 19 murders. Former associates lined up to testify against him, Flemmi and right-hand man Kevin Weeks among them, all of them trading testimony for lighter sentences.


Side by side mugshots of Catherine Greig and an elderly, white-bearded Whitey Bulger after their arrest
Catherine Greig and Bulger in custody.

Bulger's main concern wasn't the murders. It was the word "informant". He insisted he'd never been an FBI rat and claimed he'd been given immunity instead, a defence the judge refused to let him put to the jury. To a Southie gangster, being called a grass was apparently worse than being called a killer.


On 12 August 2013, the jury found him guilty on 31 of 32 counts and decided he'd been involved in 11 of the murders. That November he was sentenced to two consecutive life terms plus five years. Greig had already been given eight years for helping him hide. In 2016 she picked up another 21 months for refusing to tell a grand jury whether anyone else had helped them during the fugitive years. Whatever she knew, she kept to herself.



Moved to Hazelton and Dead Within Hours

By 2018 Bulger was 89, used a wheelchair and had serious heart problems. He'd spent eight months alone in a cell at a federal prison in Florida after being disciplined for threatening a nurse, and the Bureau of Prisons wanted him moved.


A 2022 report by the Justice Department's inspector general later found that officials tried several times to downgrade his medical status so the transfer could go ahead. More than 100 prison staff knew in advance he was heading to USP Hazelton in West Virginia, a violent and understaffed lockup, and some discussed it in front of inmates. Word spread fast. One prisoner told investigators what everyone was thinking: "He was a rat. What would you think would happen to him?"


Bulger arrived on 29 October 2018 and was put in general population rather than protective custody. At 8:20am the next morning, 30 October, guards found him bleeding heavily. Prison cameras had caught at least two inmates wheeling the 89-year-old into a corner, and what happened there was savage. He was beaten with a padlock stuffed in a sock. His eyes appeared to have been forced from their sockets, and a federal official said his attackers had also tried to cut out his tongue, the old mob punishment for a snitch. One senior law enforcement official said: "They apparently tuned him up to the point where he was unrecognizable." He was pronounced dead shortly afterwards.


The full inspector general's report found no evidence of malicious intent but listed a string of management failures and recommended action against at least six staff.


Who Killed Whitey Bulger?

Three inmates were charged. Fotios "Freddy" Geas, a former Mafia hitman from Springfield, Massachusetts, was accused of beating Bulger with a padlock in a sock. Paul DeCologero, part of a Massachusetts crime crew, was alleged to have kept watch alongside him, and Sean McKinnon was charged with acting as lookout. A prisoner told a grand jury that DeCologero had called Bulger a snitch and said they planned to kill him.


The case dragged on for years before ending in plea deals in 2024. McKinnon, who admitted lying to FBI agents, got no extra prison time. DeCologero received just over four more years. Geas, already serving life for the 2003 murder of Springfield mob boss Adolfo "Big Al" Bruno, pleaded to voluntary manslaughter and assault and was given another 25 years. His lawyer argued that, despite those early reports, the autopsy only showed a single blow to the left ear.


It's a grimly familiar ending for a man in Bulger's line of work. Mob informants have been meeting sticky ends for a century, from Abe Reles falling from a Coney Island hotel window in 1941 onwards. Bulger's family sued the Bureau of Prisons, but a federal judge threw the case out.


What Bulger Left Behind

The fallout reached far beyond Bulger himself. John Connolly was convicted in 2002 of tipping off the gang and again in 2008 of second-degree murder over John Callahan's killing, picking up a 40-year sentence. In February 2021, aged 80 and dying of cancer, he was released on medical grounds. Even Callahan's son didn't object.


Billy Bulger's career didn't survive either. Called before a congressional committee in late 2002, he took the Fifth. When he did testify the following year, under a grant of immunity, he admitted he'd spoken to Whitey on the phone after his brother went on the run and hadn't told the FBI. The pressure was enormous, and he resigned as president of the University of Massachusetts later in 2003.


Whitey in Hollywood

Bulger's story was made for the screen, and Hollywood noticed. Jack Nicholson's mob boss Frank Costello in Martin Scorsese's The Departed (2006) was loosely based on him, right down to the gangster who's secretly feeding the FBI. In 2015 Johnny Depp played him straight in Black Mass, adapted from the book by Boston Globe reporters Dick Lehr and Gerard O'Neill.


In Southie, though, Whitey's legend has mostly faded into films and true crime podcasts. What's left behind is the families of the people he killed, many of whom were murdered because a corrupt FBI agent told Bulger they'd been talking. For them, the most violent man in Boston was also one of the most protected, right up until the morning someone finally caught up with him.


Suggested Reading

Want to go deeper into Bulger's world? These are the books worth your time.


Whitey Bulger: America's Most Wanted Gangster and the Manhunt That Brought Him to Justice by Kevin Cullen and Shelley Murphy. Two Boston Globe reporters who covered Bulger for decades tell the full story, from Southie to Santa Monica.


Black Mass by Dick Lehr and Gerard O'Neill. The book that exposed Bulger's deal with the FBI and later became the Johnny Depp film.


Brutal: The Untold Story of My Life Inside Whitey Bulger's Irish Mob by Kevin Weeks and Phyllis Karas. Bulger's right-hand man spills what he saw, and it doesn't make for comfortable reading.


As an Amazon Associate, Utterly Interesting earns from qualifying purchases.

You Might Also Like

Sources

  1. Watchdog finds many failures before Whitey Bulger's killing, CBS News Boston / Associated Press

  2. Investigation and Review of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Handling of the Transfer of Inmate James Bulger, US Department of Justice Office of the Inspector General

  3. Whitey Bulger's fatal prison beating: 'He was unrecognizable', WRAL / Associated Press

  4. Bulger's attackers tried to cut out his tongue, federal official says, ABC22 & FOX44 / Associated Press

  5. A hitman serving life in prison gets more time for killing 'Whitey' Bulger, WEAU / Associated Press

  6. Inmate sentenced for role in prison killing of Boston gangster James 'Whitey' Bulger, PBS NewsHour

  7. After learning of Whitey Bulger's LSD tests, a juror has regrets, WBUR

  8. How James 'Whitey' Bulger went from the Air Force to Alcatraz, We Are The Mighty

  9. "Whitey" Bulger taken down by ex-Miss Iceland, CBS News

  10. Ex-FBI agent linked to Whitey Bulger to be freed from prison, Bangor Daily News / Associated Press

  11. Three BOP prisoners sentenced for murder of Whitey Bulger in West Virginia lockup, Prison Legal News

  12. About that time Whitey Bulger won the Mass Millions lottery, CrimeReads

  13. Boston mob boss 'Whitey' stashed his cash in Birmingham, Birmingham Post

  14. Bulger girlfriend gets 21 more months, WBUR

  15. First of several bodies is unearthed on Tenean Beach, When and Where in Boston

 
 
bottom of page