top of page

The Fall and Rise and Then Fall Again of Jimmy Swaggart

Oct 18, 2024
9 min read

Updated: Oct 8

Jimmy Swaggart crying at a microphone against a dramatic sky

In the space of about 18 months, Jimmy Swaggart helped destroy two of the biggest names in American television religion. He reported one rival preacher for adultery and watched him lose his church. He pushed for an investigation into another, Jim Bakker, and went on national television to call him a cancer. Swaggart was the last man standing, one of the most watched preachers in the country, with a ministry taking in well over $140 million a year.


Then somebody photographed him outside Room 7 of a cheap motel on the edge of New Orleans. The somebody was working for the first man he'd ruined.

Quick Answers

  • What was the Jimmy Swaggart scandal? In 1988 he was photographed at a New Orleans motel with a sex worker, Debra Murphree, and confessed on television without saying what he'd done. In 1991 police in California stopped his car with another sex worker inside.

  • Who exposed him? Marvin Gorman, a rival preacher Swaggart had accused of adultery two years earlier. Gorman's son and son-in-law staked out the motel.

  • What did he say? His 1988 confession is remembered for the words "I have sinned against you". In 1991 he told his congregation God had said it was none of their business.

  • Was he ever charged with a crime? No. The only charges were traffic citations from the 1991 stop.

  • When did Jimmy Swaggart die? On 1 July 2025, aged 90, two weeks after a cardiac arrest at his home in Baton Rouge.

The Boy From Ferriday

Swaggart was born on 15 March 1935 in Ferriday, Louisiana, a small river town that somehow produced three famous cousins in the space of a year. Jerry Lee Lewis became one of the founders of rock and roll. Mickey Gilley became a country star. Jimmy became a preacher. His father played the fiddle and started a church, the family had no electricity and by nine the boy was said to be speaking in tongues.


He married Frances Anderson in 1952, when he was 17, and spent years preaching in tiny rural churches while working part-time in the oil fields. He was ordained by the Assemblies of God in 1961, went on the radio the following year and discovered that the family gift for a piano and a crowd worked just as well for the Lord. By 1975 his weekly broadcast was going out nationwide. By 1980 it was daily.


At the peak in 1987 he had 2.1 million American viewers a week. The Associated Press put his ministry's income at about $142 million in 1986. He was a Grammy-nominated gospel singer and he preached the old-time message with real fury: against rock music, against pornography and against other preachers he thought had gone soft.


Jimmy Swaggart and his wife Frances on stage
Jimmy Swaggart and his wife Frances

Jimmy Swaggart and Jerry Lee Lewis: The Cousin Who Went the Other Way

Swaggart and Jerry Lee Lewis were born six months apart and learned the piano side by side. For a while it could have gone either way for both of them. One account of the family's story has Sam Phillips of Sun Records, the man who'd launched Elvis, wanting to start a gospel line with Swaggart as its first star. Swaggart said no because he believed he'd been called to preach. He was scraping a living in country churches while his cousin was reportedly making $20,000 a week.


It didn't last for Lewis either. In 1958 the press found out that he'd married his 13-year-old cousin Myra, and the scandal nearly finished him. So Ferriday produced two cousins, one sacred and one profane, and both ended up best known to the general public for a sex scandal. They stayed close anyway. In 2022 they recorded a gospel album together, The Boys From Ferriday, and when Lewis died that October it was Swaggart who spoke at the funeral in their home town. He told the mourners he had "lost the brother I never had".


He Took Down Two Rivals First

The first was Marvin Gorman, a fellow Assemblies of God minister in New Orleans whose own television show was growing fast. In 1986 Swaggart told the denomination's leaders that Gorman had been unfaithful to his wife. Gorman admitted one affair. He was defrocked, his ministry collapsed and he went bankrupt. He always maintained that Swaggart and his allies had gone much further than the truth, spreading rumours of a string of affairs to finish him off, and in 1987 he sued for $90 million.


The second was Jim Bakker. When word reached Swaggart that the host of The PTL Club had paid off a church secretary, he took it to the same church leadership and then to CNN, where he told Larry King that Bakker was "a cancer in the body of Christ". Bakker resigned in March 1987 and the scandals that followed sent him to prison. Swaggart insisted he'd only done his duty. He was also now the biggest name left in the business.



Who Exposed Jimmy Swaggart? Room 7 of the Travel Inn

Gorman had lost everything and had time on his hands. He'd heard that Swaggart was a regular visitor to the Travel Inn, a motel on Airline Highway in the suburbs of New Orleans, so his son Randy and his son-in-law Garland Bilbo kept watch on it. In 1987 they got what they were waiting for: photographs of America's best-known moral crusader outside Room 7 with a sex worker named Debra Murphree.


Jimmy Swaggart beside the words I have sinned against you
Swaggart trying to save face

The version of the story that's passed into legend has them letting the air out of Swaggart's tyres so he couldn't leave before Gorman got there. Whether or not that detail is exactly right, Gorman did arrive, and the two men had it out in the car park.


What Gorman wanted wasn't money. He wanted his name back. The deal, as it's usually told, was that Swaggart would go to the church leadership, admit he'd lied about the extent of Gorman's sins and help get him reinstated. In return the photographs would stay in a drawer. Swaggart did nothing for months. In February 1988 Gorman ran out of patience and took the pictures to the same officials who had defrocked him.


What Did Jimmy Swaggart Actually Do? "I Have Sinned"

On 18 February 1988 Swaggart was called before the Assemblies of God's leaders in Springfield, Missouri. He was reportedly argumentative. Three days later, on Sunday 21 February, he stood in front of about 7,000 people at his Family Worship Center in Baton Rouge, with the cameras running, and wept. He apologised to his wife, his son, his church and his God. The line everyone remembers was addressed upwards: "I have sinned against you. I beg you to forgive me."

It's one of the most replayed pieces of religious television ever broadcast, and it's worth noticing what isn't in it. He never said what the sin was.



Who Was Debra Murphree?

The woman in the photographs filled in the gap four days later. Debra Murphree was a sex worker who operated out of the Travel Inn and had a young daughter. She told reporters that she and Swaggart had never had sex. He paid her to pose.


That summer she sold the full story to Penthouse, which for a preacher who'd spent years denouncing pornography was about as bad as it could get. UPI's report on the interview had her describing around 20 visits at $30 or $40 a time, and its headline passed on her verdict that he was cheap. After the magazine came out she dropped out of public view, which is more than her most famous client ever managed.



Defrocked, and Carrying On Anyway

The church gave him two different punishments. The Louisiana district suggested three months out of the pulpit. The national leadership overruled them: a year without preaching and two years of supervised rehabilitation. Swaggart did the three months and went back on stage that spring. The Assemblies of God defrocked him, and he responded by taking his church and his broadcasts independent.


The audience didn't follow. NPR's obituary has the ministry's income falling from around $150 million a year to $11 million. The comedians moved in. Ozzy Osbourne, whose music Swaggart had once called "pornography and degenerative filth", put out a single called Miracle Man that autumn and filmed the video in a church full of pigs, wearing a Swaggart mask.



The bills kept coming. In January 1990 the US Supreme Court ruled unanimously against Jimmy Swaggart Ministries in a fight with California, which wanted $118,294.54 in sales tax on Bibles, books and tapes he'd sold in the state. He had argued that taxing religious material was unconstitutional. All nine justices disagreed, and the case still carries his name.


Then Gorman's lawsuit came to trial. In 1991 a New Orleans jury found that Swaggart had defamed him and awarded damages in the millions, and after three more years of appeals the two sides settled for $1.85 million, paid by Swaggart's insurers. Gorman's lawyer said his client had got what he'd wanted from that motel car park: "Marvin Gorman got his name restored".


Gorman went back to preaching and outlived the feud by more than 20 years. When he died in January 2017, the Assemblies of God's own news service ran a tribute from the head of the denomination that had once thrown him out.



Indio, 1991: "None of Your Business"

A comeback was under way when it happened again. On 11 October 1991 police in Indio, California, in a district they'd been targeting for drugs and prostitution, pulled over a 1989 Jaguar that was being driven on the wrong side of the road. The driver was Swaggart. He was cited for that, for having an unregistered car and for not wearing a seat belt. His passenger was Rosemary Garcia, 31, who told local television she was a prostitute. Her account of the pick-up was brief: "He asked for sex. He was shaking." She said he'd started swerving when he saw the police car behind him because he was trying to hide his pornographic magazines.


There were no tears this time. Back in Baton Rouge on 17 October he told his congregation he'd consulted the Almighty about whether to explain himself. The answer he reported was this: "The Lord told me it's flat none of your business." His son Donnie then announced that his father was stepping down for a while to get help.


The Long Afterlife

He came back, of course. Swaggart never regained the audience of the 1980s but he never left the air either. The Family Worship Center kept its doors open, the ministry built its own radio and television operation, the SonLife Broadcasting Network, and Frances and Donnie took on bigger roles in running it. The crowds were smaller and older. They were also loyal.

He could still cause trouble. In 2004 he told his congregation what he'd do to any gay man who looked at him the wrong way, a remark about killing that he later apologised for.


Stone mansion with a large pool and fountain at dusk, Jimmy Swaggart's home in Baton Rouge, Louisiana
Swaggart's house in Baton Rouge, Louisiana

How Did Jimmy Swaggart Die?

On 15 June 2025 Swaggart suffered a cardiac arrest at home in Baton Rouge. He died on 1 July, aged 90. Frances, his wife since 1952, and Donnie survived him, and the funeral was held at the Family Worship Center, the same building where he'd made the confession 37 years earlier. A grandson, Gabriel, is a preacher too.


Who Runs Jimmy Swaggart Ministries Now?

The family does. Religion News Service's obituary names Donnie Swaggart as the ministry's leader, with the radio network his father started in 1995 and the television network that followed in 2010 both still broadcasting from Baton Rouge. The same piece puts Jimmy's lifetime sales at more than 17 million recordings and notes that he was due to be inducted into the Southern Gospel Music Hall of Fame a few months after he died. Whatever else happened, the music was never in dispute.

His old rival Jim Bakker outlived him by 15 months. Between them they'd shown American television what a preacher could build, and then what it looked like when it fell on him. It's the same lesson Marjoe Gortner had tried to teach the country on film a decade and a half before either of them was caught.

FAQ

Was Jimmy Swaggart related to Jerry Lee Lewis? Yes. They were cousins, born six months apart in Ferriday, Louisiana, and the country singer Mickey Gilley was a cousin to both.

Did Jimmy Swaggart go to prison? No. Neither scandal led to criminal charges. He was cited for traffic offences after the 1991 stop in California and lost a defamation case to Marvin Gorman, which was settled out of court.

Is Jimmy Swaggart's church still open? Yes. The Family Worship Center in Baton Rouge is still running under his son Donnie, and it's where his funeral was held in July 2025.

You Might Also Like

Sources

  1. Televangelist Jimmy Swaggart, whose ministry was toppled by prostitution scandals, dies at 90 (Associated Press via Scripps News, 1 July 2025)

  2. Glen Jeansonne and David Luhrssen, Jimmy Swaggart (64 Parishes, Louisiana Endowment for the Humanities)

  3. Evangelist Jimmy Swaggart Tearfully Confesses His Adultery (EBSCO Research Starters)

  4. Jimmy Swaggart dies: How a photo with a prostitute triggered the preacher's downfall (WION, July 2025)

  5. Remembering televangelist Jimmy Swaggart (NPR, 1 July 2025)

  6. When Ozzy Osbourne filled a church with pigs for Miracle Man (Ultimate Classic Rock)

  7. Swaggart Ministries v. Board of Equalization, 493 U.S. 378 (1990) (Justia)

  8. Swaggart agrees to pay $1.85 million to end fight (Deseret News, 27 April 1994)

  9. Swaggart's insurance pays rival $1.85 million in lawsuit settlement (Deseret News, 30 April 1994)

  10. Self-described prostitute in Swaggart car (Seattle Times, 12 October 1991)

  11. Swaggart: God says 'It's none of your business' (Seattle Times, 17 October 1991)

  12. Rev. Jimmy Swaggart passes away at age 90; funeral services announced (WAFB, 1 July 2025)

  13. Jimmy Swaggart Dead at 90. His Close Ties to Country Music (Saving Country Music, 5 July 2025)

  14. Family and fans bid farewell to Jerry Lee Lewis (Associated Press via ClickOnDetroit, 5 November 2022)

  15. Prostitute says Swaggart 'kinky and cheap too' (UPI, 25 May 1988)

  16. Marvin E. Gorman Dies (AG News, January 2017)

  17. Jimmy Swaggart, controversial televangelist and Southern gospel legend, dies at 90 (Religion News Service, 1 July 2025)


 
 
bottom of page