top of page

The 2002 Moscow Theatre Siege: A Tragedy in Three Acts

Jun 4, 2025
11 min read

Updated: Oct 23

Collage of Russian special forces in the Dubrovka Theatre auditorium, unconscious hostages slumped in red seats and medics carrying a man outside

Just after 9pm on Wednesday 23 October 2002, the second act of the musical Nord-Ost had barely got going when a man in camouflage walked onto the stage and fired into the air. A lot of the audience thought it was part of the show. It wasn't. Around 40 Chechen gunmen and women had just taken more than 900 people hostage in a theatre four miles from the Kremlin.


Fifty-seven hours later it was over. Every hostage-taker was dead, and so were 130 of the people they'd captured. Hardly any of them were killed by the militants. They died from a mystery gas their own government pumped into the building, and from a rescue that was nowhere near ready for what came next. Russia still hasn't officially said what that gas was.

Quick Answers

  • What was the Moscow theatre siege? A hostage crisis at the Dubrovka Theatre in Moscow, 23 to 26 October 2002, during a performance of the musical Nord-Ost.

  • Who carried it out? Around 40 Chechen militants led by 23-year-old Movsar Barayev, demanding Russian troops leave Chechnya.

  • How many people died? The official toll is 130 hostages plus all 40 attackers. Survivors' groups believe the real number of hostage deaths is higher.

  • What gas was used? Russia only ever called it a fentanyl derivative. British scientists later found traces of carfentanil and remifentanil on survivors.

  • Was Russia found at fault? Yes. In 2011 the European Court of Human Rights ruled the rescue was badly planned and the investigation inadequate, though it didn't condemn the use of gas itself.

A Patriotic Musical in a Factory Theatre

The Dubrovka Theatre wasn't some glitzy West End type venue. It was the House of Culture of State Ball-Bearing Plant No. 1, a Soviet-era workers' club in a working-class bit of south-east Moscow that had been turned over to Nord-Ost. The show was based on Veniamin Kaverin's adventure novel The Two Captains and it was billed as Russia's first Broadway-style musical, complete with a real plane that landed on stage.


It was proudly patriotic and a real family favourite. That October night the place was almost full. There were children in the cast and plenty more in the audience, along with office workers, pensioners, couples on dates and a handful of foreigners.


A person bowing at a snowy memorial covered in flowers outside the Dubrovka Theatre, with a large Nord-Ost poster of seagulls and blue sky behind
The memorial outside the Dubrovka Theatre in recent years

Among them was Sandy Booker, a 49-year-old engineer from Oklahoma. He'd met Svetlana Gubareva online and they'd come to celebrate her lodging her visa application at the US embassy. They'd brought her 13-year-old daughter Sasha. All three were about to become hostages, and only Svetlana would come out alive.


Movsar Barayev and the Women in Black

The gunmen were led by Movsar Barayev, the 23-year-old nephew of Arbi Barayev, a notoriously brutal Chechen warlord killed by Russian forces in 2001. Here's the kicker. About ten days before the siege, Russian forces had claimed they'd killed Movsar too, in the North Caucasus. He turned up in Moscow very much alive.


Two side-by-side photos of Movsar Barayev, one with a full beard and one in military camouflage and a dark beanie
Movsar Barayev

Shamil Basayev, Chechnya's most wanted rebel commander, later claimed he'd ordered the attack. Moscow prosecutors would eventually say the plotters had recruited 52 people for the job, though only 40 actually went in. Nineteen of those were women, many dressed in black with explosive belts strapped round their waists. The Russian press called them black widows, because a lot of them had lost husbands, brothers or sons in the war.


That war was the whole point. Russia had poured troops back into Chechnya in 1999 and the fighting had been savage, with bombed-out towns, mass disappearances and brutal sweep operations on villages. The hostage-takers wanted it stopped and the troops gone, and they made it very clear they'd come to Moscow expecting to die.


Act One: Taking the Theatre

The militants moved fast. Some backstage staff and actors escaped through windows and side doors in the first chaotic minutes, but more than 900 people ended up herded into the auditorium. The attackers wired the hall with explosives, including a big device in the middle of the stalls, and posted women with bombs among the seats. If anyone stormed the building, they said, they'd bring the whole place down.


Three hostage-takers in camouflage sitting in a tiled room, one in a balaclava holding a rifle
Leaders of the hostage-takers

Within the first hours they let around 15 children under the age of 12 go. Sasha Gubareva, at 13, was too old. Some Muslims and a few foreigners were released over the next couple of days too, and Barayev's group repeatedly said foreign nationals weren't their target.


Life inside got grim very quickly. People were stuck in their seats with barely any food or water. The orchestra pit became the toilet. The militants kept radios on and got visibly twitchy whenever the news hinted at an assault, and they threatened to shoot ten hostages for every one of their own killed.


Two armed and masked hostage-takers standing among seated hostages inside the theatre auditorium
Inside the theatre during the siege

The Perfume Seller Who Walked Into the Siege

One of the strangest moments came in the early hours of 24 October. Olga Romanova, a 26-year-old who worked at a perfume shop nearby, somehow got through the police cordon on her own and walked straight into the theatre. She reportedly marched into the hall and started shouting at the hostages to stand up to their captors.


Black and white portrait of a smiling young woman with short hair in a patterned jumper
Olga Romanova

The militants decided she was an FSB plant and shot her dead. When medics carried her body out later, police first told the press she was a hostage killed trying to escape. Her real story only came out afterwards. There's an odd postscript too. NTV's news anchor that night was also called Olga Romanova, and she later said hearing her own name read out as the first victim was the one time she broke protocol and asked to phone her mum on air.



She wasn't the only one. Later in the siege a man named in the European Court of Human Rights judgment only as Mr Vl. got into the building, reportedly looking for his son. He was shot too, and while the militants were firing at another man, a hostage was hit and later died in hospital.


Act Two: Talking to the Gunmen

Outside, the Kremlin projected calm while hardly anyone with real hostage negotiation training got near the militants. Instead an odd assortment of public figures went in. The singer and MP Joseph Kobzon walked out with a handful of hostages, children among them. Politicians Irina Khakamada and Boris Nemtsov had a go. Chechen-born Duma deputy Aslambek Aslakhanov shuttled messages back and forth.

Two men in white coats dragging a body across the ground outside the theatre entrance, with parked cars behind them
Doctors removing the body of Olga Romanova

The journalist Anna Politkovskaya, who'd spent years reporting on Chechnya, was one of the people the militants actually asked for. She took in water and juice. The paediatrician Leonid Roshal went in with medicine and came out saying the hostages weren't being beaten, but they were suffering badly from the conditions and the fear.


Relatives waited out the three days in a vocational school nearby, desperate for news and begging the authorities not to storm the place. Russia offered the gunmen safe passage to a third country if they freed everyone. They refused. By the morning of 26 October the authorities had stopped pretending negotiations were going anywhere.



Act Three: The Gas

At around 5am on 26 October, special forces started pumping an aerosol into the theatre through the ventilation system. Some hostages smelled it and thought there was a fire. Some of the militants pulled on masks or started shouting. Within minutes, almost everyone in the hall was unconscious, including the women with their hands on detonators.


Hostage-takers with covered faces slumped dead in red theatre seats, with a bag on the floor in the dim auditorium
Dead hostage-takers in the auditorium after the raid

Then FSB Alpha and Vympel teams went in. The fighting was short and one-sided. All 40 hostage-takers were killed, many of them shot where they slumped. Not a single bomb went off. As a military operation, it worked.


As a rescue, it was a disaster. Hundreds of people were lying unconscious from a powerful opioid, and the emergency services hadn't been told what they were dealing with. Many victims were carried out and laid on their backs on the pavement and the steps, where some choked as their airways closed. City buses were drafted in to ferry casualties to hospital. Ambulances got stuck in traffic. Doctors ran short of naloxone, the antidote.


A man carrying an unconscious woman through a smashed doorway at night, surrounded by emergency workers
Hostages being carried out of the theatre

That afternoon officials were still insisting no hostages had died. By the next day the official count was in the dozens. It settled at 130, all but a handful killed by the gas. Two of them were Nord-Ost's child stars, 14-year-old Kristina Kurbatova and 13-year-old Arseny Kurilenko, who were buried side by side at Moscow's Vagankovskoye Cemetery. Kristina had been a big Tolkien fan, and The Lord of the Rings was her favourite film. In total the show lost 17 members of its company.


Exhausted rescued hostages sitting on a city bus at night, some embracing, with steamed-up windows
Freed hostages on one of the buses used to evacuate the theatre

Sasha Gubareva and Sandy Booker were among the dead. Svetlana woke up in hospital and heard on the radio that her daughter and her fiancé had both been killed.



So What Was the Gas?

For days, Moscow said nothing. Doctors treating survivors were working blind. Eventually, on 30 October, Health Minister Yuri Shevchenko said it was based on fentanyl, and that was about as far as the Russian state ever went. In court and in official papers it's been called a gaseous substance or something similar ever since.


The best answer came from Britain a decade later. A team at the Ministry of Defence's labs at Porton Down analysed clothing from two British survivors and urine from a third. They didn't find plain fentanyl at all. They found carfentanil, a sedative used to knock out elephants and other big animals, and remifentanil, a short-acting anaesthetic. They also found norcarfentanil, a breakdown product of carfentanil, in the urine sample.



Carfentanil is roughly 10,000 times as potent as morphine, and there's very little gap between a dose that knocks you out and one that kills you. Now picture that sprayed into a hall full of people who'd barely eaten or drunk for three days, some of them elderly, with the dose depending on how close you happened to be sitting to a vent. Survivors' groups have always argued it was never going to end any other way.


The Cover-Up

Four Russian special forces soldiers in camouflage and helmets standing with rifles among red theatre seats, the floor littered with debris
Special forces inside the auditorium after the raid

Putin went on television, apologised for not being able to save everyone and declared 28 October a national day of mourning. He also called the operation a success, and that's how the state has framed it ever since.


Families were told their loved ones had died of heart failure or chronic illness. Tatyana Karpova, whose son Alexander was killed, said she was told his kidneys and liver had already been diseased. Alexander was a musician who'd just translated the musical Chicago into Russian, and he and his wife had been given their tickets by a friend who produced Nord-Ost. Karpova went on to lead the victims' group named after the show, and its own investigation found that 97 of the 130 who died got no medical help at all. She couldn't get past how anyone could call that a triumph. "How can you call an operation a 'great success' when so many people died?" she asked.


A 2003 domestic inquiry decided the hostages had essentially died of natural causes, with the gas playing at most an indirect role. The criminal investigation into the attack dragged on and was suspended in 2007. Nobody in the security services was ever charged with anything, and Russia didn't publicly acknowledge that there had been casualties during the special operation itself until March 2017, almost 15 years later.


Vladimir Putin and doctors at a hospital bedside as a nurse in a blue cap adjusts a patient's drip
Putin visiting rescued hostages at the Sklifosovsky Institute of Emergency Medicine

Strasbourg Steps In

With nowhere left to go at home, 64 survivors and relatives took Russia to the European Court of Human Rights. On 20 December 2011 the court handed down its judgment in Finogenov and Others v. Russia, and it was a mixed result.


The judges didn't find that using the gas breached the right to life. The bombs were real, the hostage-takers were armed and the authorities had to act. But the court ruled that Russia had broken Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights with a rescue that was poorly planned and carried out, and again by failing to investigate properly. It awarded the applicants more than €1.2 million in damages.


Not everyone thought that went far enough. Writing in the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, critics warned the ruling effectively waved through the use of incapacitating chemicals by police and soldiers, even when nobody can control the dose.



The Questions That Won't Go Away


How did 40 armed militants, explosives and all, drive across Russia and walk into a Moscow theatre without anyone noticing? That question has fed conspiracy theories for more than 20 years.


The most persistent centres on Khanpasha Terkibayev, a Chechen who Politkovskaya tracked down in 2003. He claimed he'd been inside the theatre with Barayev's group and walked out before the raid, and she believed he was working for Russian intelligence. The Jamestown Foundation reported MPs formally asking prosecutors what they knew about his role. Terkibayev died in a car crash in Chechnya later that year.


Armed Russian security personnel detaining a woman on a dark street near armoured vehicles
Security forces outside the theatre during the siege

Sergei Yushenkov, the liberal MP who'd been pushing for an independent inquiry into the siege and the 1999 apartment bombings, was shot dead outside his Moscow home in April 2003. Politkovskaya was murdered in 2006. So was former FSB officer Alexander Litvinenko, poisoned with polonium in London after accusing his old employers of a hand in the siege. None of that proves a plot, but it's easy to see why so many Russians don't trust the official story.


Two years after Dubrovka, Chechen militants took more than 1,000 people hostage at a school in Beslan. The Russian state's response there followed a horribly familiar pattern, which we've covered in the Beslan school siege and the story Russia still struggles to tell.


Hostages lying motionless across red seats in the dimly lit theatre auditorium after the gas attack
Victims in the auditorium

The Show Went On

Incredibly, Nord-Ost came back. In February 2003 the cast returned to the same stage, opening with nothing more than a minute's silence. Every surviving member of the company signed up, and former hostages sat in the audience. One of the producers admitted they could see the irony of a show about the painful parts of Russian history becoming one itself. Ticket sales never recovered and the production closed within a few months.


Every October, people still gather in the square outside the theatre. On the 20th anniversary in 2022 they lit 130 candles and let go of 130 white balloons, one for each hostage. Dmitry Milovidov, who now runs the Nord-Ost group, said nobody even knows how many former hostages have died early since, or what illnesses they've been left with. A film about the siege, Ivan Tverdovsky's Conference, was screened for the anniversary and drew just a few dozen people.


Irina Khramtsova lost her father at Dubrovka. Speaking to AFP on the 20th anniversary, she summed up why the survivors keep asking questions nobody in power wants to answer. "By forgetting our mistakes, we make them again,"

Suggested Reading

Want to go deeper into Dubrovka and Russia's war in Chechnya? These are worth a look.


The 2002 Dubrovka and 2004 Beslan Hostage Crises by John B. Dunlop. A forensic look at both sieges and the awkward questions about what the Russian security services knew and when.


A Small Corner of Hell: Dispatches from Chechnya by Anna Politkovskaya. Politkovskaya's reporting from the war that drove the hostage-takers to Moscow, including her own account of going into the theatre.


Darkness at Dawn: The Rise of the Russian Criminal State by David Satter. The wider story of 1990s and early Putin-era Russia, including the apartment bombings that kicked off the second Chechen war.


As an Amazon Associate, Utterly Interesting earns from qualifying purchases.

You Might Also Like

Sources

  1. Finogenov and Others v. Russia, judgment of 20 December 2011, European Court of Human Rights via BAILII

  2. Analysis of Clothing and Urine from Moscow Theatre Siege Casualties Reveals Carfentanil and Remifentanil Use, Journal of Analytical Toxicology (2012)

  3. Dubrovka Theatre Siege Victims Remain Haunted 20 Years On, The Moscow Times / AFP

  4. No Closure for Victims of Theater Hostage Crisis, 12 Years On, The Moscow Times

  5. MT Classic: A Foreigner's Nightmare in Dubrovka, The Moscow Times

  6. At a scene of tragedy in Moscow, an act of hope, The Christian Science Monitor

  7. Jewish victims of the Moscow theatre siege, Jewish Telegraphic Agency

  8. Funeral for two teenagers who died in the Moscow theatre siege, Reuters

  9. Terror act at Dubrovka Theatre Centre (October 23-26, 2002), Caucasian Knot

  10. Relatives of victims of Dubrovka terror act declared their no confidence in investigation, Caucasian Knot

  11. How many hostages were killed by the terrorists during the 57-hour siege?, Jamestown Foundation, North Caucasus Weekly

  12. Role of Chechen hostage-taker remains a mystery, Jamestown Foundation, North Caucasus Weekly

  13. Probe of Dubrovka Theater Siege Suspended, Jamestown Foundation, North Caucasus Weekly

  14. 14 years after Moscow terrorist attack that killed 130 people, JAMnews

  15. European court ruling on the Moscow theatre siege gas, Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists

  16. Russia marks Moscow theatre siege anniversary, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty

 
 
bottom of page