top of page

Joe 'the Boss' Masseria: The Man Who Dodged Bullets Until the Day He Didn't

Jan 18, 2025
12 min read

Updated: Oct 6


Black-and-white collage shows a man's portrait, a bloody crime scene, and a couple. Text reads: Giuseppe "Joe the Boss" Masseria.

At about 3pm on Wednesday 15 April 1931, the most powerful Mafia boss in New York was sitting in the back of a little Italian restaurant in Coney Island playing cards. A few minutes later he was sprawled on the floor with four bullets in his back and one in his head, and within days the story of his death had been polished into one of gangland's great legends. He'd eaten a last big meal. He died clutching the ace of spades. Lucky Luciano had nipped to the toilet at just the right moment.


Some of that is true. Some of it almost certainly isn't. This is the life and death of Giuseppe Masseria, the man the papers called Joe the Boss, with the folklore and the facts pulled apart.

Quick Answers

●      Who was Joe Masseria? A Sicilian-born gangster who became the dominant Mafia boss in New York in the late 1920s. His organisation later became the Genovese family.

●      When and where was he killed? Around 3pm on 15 April 1931 at the Nuova Villa Tammaro restaurant, 2715 West 15th Street, Coney Island.

●      Who killed him? Nobody was ever charged. Vito Genovese, Albert Anastasia, Joe Adonis and Bugsy Siegel are usually named, but that's tradition rather than proof.

●      Was he really holding the ace of spades? The card in the famous photo was very probably put there afterwards for the cameras.

●      Why was he killed? His own lieutenants, led by Lucky Luciano, did a deal with his rival Salvatore Maranzano to end the Castellammarese War.

Lucky Luciano mugshot, NYC POLICE 72321, black and white profile.
'Lucky' Luciano

From Menfi to the Bowery

Masseria was born on 17 January 1886 in Menfi, in the Agrigento province of western Sicily. According to American Mafia History, he was the only child of a tailor and left for America at 17, reportedly to escape a murder indictment back home. The Mob Museum dates his arrival to 1903.


He was a small-time crook for years before he was anybody's boss. Gang Rule lists a suspended sentence in 1907 for breaking into an apartment on Elizabeth Street, an arrest the same year for Black Hand extortion threats against his own family, a saloon he ran with his wife on Forsyth Street and a botched break-in in New Jersey in 1911.


Then came the job that put him away. In the early hours of 13 April 1913 a gang tried to rob Simpson's pawnshop at 164 Bowery. At about 8am a police officer stopped a 27-year-old Masseria coming out of a building at 150 Elizabeth Street. He said he was throwing out old bread. Detectives found burglary tools in the cellar, and fingerprints on them tied him to the job, an early example of fingerprint evidence being used in a New York courtroom, according to Gang Rule. Historian Thomas Hunt's account on American Mafia says Masseria got four to six years and entered Sing Sing on 26 May 1913.



The Man Who Could Dodge Bullets

When he got out he fell in with the Morello organisation, the first real Mafia family in New York, and in the early 1920s he fought his way to the top of what was left of it. 1922 was the bloodiest year. On 8 May, Morello ally Vincenzo Terranova was shot dead outside 338 East 116th Street. That same month Masseria's rival Umberto Valenti ambushed him on Grand Street, wounding several bystanders, according to Gang Rule.


On 9 August 1922 they came for him again. Two gunmen opened fire as he left his apartment and Masseria ducked into a shop on Second Avenue. When police found him afterwards he was unhurt, holding a straw hat with two bullet holes in it, per CultureNow and American Mafia History. Accounts of how many passers-by were hit vary; Gang Rule says eight people were wounded, and some versions add dead bystanders and even a horse. Either way, the story made him famous as the man who could dodge bullets.


Aerial view of Sing Sing prison on the bank of the Hudson River
Aerial view of Sing Sing prison, where Masseria served a 4 and a half year prison sentence.

Two days later Masseria hit back, and he did it with a lunch invitation. On 11 August 1922 Valenti was lured to a supposed peace meeting at John's, an Italian restaurant at 302 East 12th Street in what's now the East Village. According to Infamous New York, he came out at around noon with six companions and two well-dressed gunmen opened up on him. One is said to have been a young Lucky Luciano and the other probably Vito Genovese. Valenti, hit in the chest, drew his own revolver and kept firing until it was empty. A teenage witness told reporters, "It was the coolest thing I ever saw." Valenti staggered to a taxi on the corner and died in it. A street sweeper and a young girl visiting from New Haven, Connecticut, were hit by stray bullets.


Here's the thing: John's is still there. It opened in 1908 and ran as a speakeasy during Prohibition, serving wine and whiskey in espresso cups in case of a raid, according to Village Preservation. Infamous New York notes it's since been used as a location for The Sopranos and Boardwalk Empire. You can still eat a plate of meatballs a few yards from where Valenti fell.


With Valenti gone, Masseria's reputation only grew. On 10 October 1928 the old boss of bosses, Salvatore D'Aquila, was shot dead on the corner of Avenue A and 13th Street, per Thomas Hunt's list of New York crime family bosses. Gang Rule says Masseria ordered it. He took the title for himself, with Giuseppe Morello as his number two.



Joe the Boss

By the end of the 1920s Masseria ran the biggest Mafia family in New York, with men like Lucky Luciano, Frank Costello and Albert Anastasia working under him. He was short, about 5ft 4in, heavy and famously fond of his food. Joe Bonanno, who fought against him in the war that followed, remembered in his memoir A Man of Honor that Masseria "attacked a plate of spaghetti as if he were a drooling mastiff," as quoted by Den of Geek. Gangsters Inc says some underworld figures called him "the Chinaman" behind his back because of the way he squinted, though never to his face. He had gold teeth and a penthouse at 15 West 81st Street on Manhattan's Upper West Side.


He was also a lot less old-fashioned than he's usually painted. The standard line is that Masseria was a stubborn old Sicilian who refused to work with Jewish and Irish gangsters. But early on 28 February 1930, police raided a top-floor suite in a Miami Beach hotel and arrested 18 men, including Masseria and a man giving his name as Charles Lucania, better known as Lucky Luciano. They seized $73,575 in cash and a handgun. According to Hunt's account of the raid on American Mafia, Masseria was fined $800 and told to leave town. It was the first time the press publicly linked Luciano to the boss. (You'll sometimes read that Bugsy Siegel was arrested there too. He isn't on the list of names.)


The Castellammarese War

In 1930 Masseria's grip started to slip. His main rival was Salvatore Maranzano, a boss from Castellammare del Golfo in Sicily whose followers gave the war that followed its name. It was a nasty, messy fight over who would rule the Mafia in America, as Britannica outlines, and the bodies piled up fast. Hunt's records put the key killings like this:

●      26 February 1930: Gaetano Reina, a Bronx boss who'd been drifting towards Maranzano, was shot dead outside his girlfriend's apartment building on Sheridan Avenue.

●      15 August 1930: Giuseppe Morello, the Clutch Hand, the old godfather of the New York Mafia and Masseria's right-hand man, was murdered.

●      5 November 1930: Al Mineo and Steve Ferrigno, two of Masseria's most important allies, were ambushed in the courtyard of the Alhambra Apartments on Pelham Parkway in the Bronx.

Losing Morello, Mineo and Ferrigno within three months was a disaster. Masseria was running out of senior men, and the ones he had left were starting to do the maths.


It wasn't going well for Masseria, and his own men could see it. Luciano, Genovese and the younger members of the family were making far more money from bootlegging and gambling than from fighting a war over old Sicilian loyalties. According to the memoirs of mafioso Nicola Gentile, the plan to kill their own boss was agreed with Maranzano in advance: get rid of Masseria and the war stops.


Street scene with people, vintage cars, and ornate building facade.
Scene at 2715 West 15th Street, Coney Island, the location where Joe 'The Boss' Masseria was murdered.

15 April 1931

The Nuova Villa Tammaro was a small Italian restaurant run by Gerardo Scarpato at 2715 West 15th Street in Coney Island. It was a long way from Masseria's Manhattan territory, and in April the beach crowds hadn't arrived yet, so it would have been quiet on a Wednesday afternoon. That was probably the point. Masseria arrived in the early afternoon with two bodyguards, reportedly in the steel-armoured sedan he'd taken to using since the war began, according to Crime and Cocktails.


He wasn't there for a feast. According to the Mob Museum's Christian Cipollini, he ordered light: bread, wine and coffee. Then the table settled down to a game of pinochle. The popular version has Lucky Luciano sitting opposite him, which fits everything we know about the plot, though who exactly was at the table is one of the things the accounts disagree on (more on that below).

Some time before the shooting, Scarpato left. He'd later have plenty of time to regret it, but that afternoon it looked like the owner had simply stepped out.


At around 3pm, gunmen walked in and opened fire. The New York Times and the Herald Tribune reported that two well-dressed men came in and that "some 20 shots were fired", according to a listing for the Times' 17 April 1931 edition on Rare Newspapers. Other retellings have three or four gunmen. What's not in doubt is where the bullets ended up. Masseria was hit four times in the back and once in the head, most likely while he was still sitting at the card table. He never got the chance to dodge these ones.


The autopsy was carried out by Dr G.W. Ruger. He recovered two .38 bullets, and powder burns showed at least one shooter had been standing just inches away, per Gangsters Inc. His heart, lungs, liver and brain were all badly damaged. He was 45.


The killers left the way they'd come and drove off in a waiting car. They didn't bother taking the guns with them: police recovered two revolvers in an alley next to the restaurant, according to the same Times report. Getting rid of the weapons straight away was already standard practice, since an unregistered gun found at the scene told detectives almost nothing, while one found in your pocket later could hang you.


And the bodyguards? None of the accounts suggests they fired a shot or were so much as scratched. Whether they'd been paid off, warned off or simply knew better than to get involved has never been established, but a boss with a reputation for dodging bullets was killed with his own protection in the room. That tells you most of what you need to know about how the hit was arranged.


The New York papers couldn't agree on much. The Daily News went for drama and had Masseria dying "with the ace of spades, the death card, clutched in a bejeweled paw," while the Times was more cautious. The next morning the Times summed him up with a line that's been quoted ever since: "It took ten years and a lot of shooting to kill Giuseppe Masseria," as quoted by Gangsters Inc. A day later its headline was simply Police Mystified in Slaying of 'Boss', with 40 detectives assigned to the case and the familiar gangland wall of silence.


Detectives questioned Scarpato, Sam Pollaccia, Augie Pisano and the Harlem boss Ciro Terranova, according to the Mob Museum. Everyone had been somewhere else, and nobody had seen anything. Nobody was ever charged.


Deceased person's bloodied body lying on the ground.
The aftermath of Joe Masseria's assassination in a Coney Island restaurant on April 15, 1931, with an ace of spades conspicuously in hand, likely placed as a macabre symbol.

The Myths That Grew Up Around It

He dined on bullets. It's a great headline and the title the story has been told under for decades, but the autopsy found almost nothing in his stomach. Gangsters Inc says it contained only a small amount of bile, and Pulp International suggests he may have been too worried about poison to eat anything much at all in company.

The ace of spades. The famous photo shows Masseria sprawled on his back with a playing card in his right hand. Cards had genuinely been scattered in the chaos, but the ace in his hand was probably put there afterwards. As a 2012 New York Times Q&A, republished by Cosa Nostra News, put it, "that card, however, might have been staged." Pulp International goes further and says it was very likely placed by a photographer. It's a bit like the cigar in Carmine Galante's mouth half a century later: the image that everyone remembers may be partly a set-up.

Luciano was in the toilet. The story usually goes that Luciano excused himself to the bathroom just before the gunmen came in, so he could honestly say he saw nothing. It's possible, and it's certainly how he'd have wanted it done. But it's a story told after the fact, and nobody independent was there to confirm it.

The killers. The four men usually named are Vito Genovese, Albert Anastasia, Joe Adonis and Bugsy Siegel. National Crime Syndicate is honest about it: they're the men usually named, not men proven to have done it. Gangsters Inc adds Joseph Coppola to the list of suspects. The truth is we don't know for certain who pulled the triggers.

The great purge. Five months later Luciano had Maranzano killed too, on 10 September 1931. That's often said to have been followed by a nationwide massacre of Maranzano's allies, 40 or even 90 men in a single night. Thomas Hunt has picked that apart on American Mafia, finding only a handful of linked killings and tracing the big numbers back to one uncorroborated account from 1939.



What Happened Afterwards

According to the Mob Museum, Luciano sent a message to Maranzano through an intermediary, Vincenzo Troia, saying they'd killed Masseria "not to serve him, but for our own personal reasons." It was a warning, and Maranzano didn't heed it. Within months Luciano was running the show himself, and the Commission he set up afterwards shaped the American Mafia for the rest of the century.

Masseria got a big send-off. The Mob Museum says he was laid out at his penthouse on West 81st Street in a $15,000 bronze casket. A few weeks later his 19-year-old daughter, Vinitia, died of illness, and the papers, never ones to miss an angle, said she'd died of a broken heart.


Gerardo Scarpato didn't do so well. The restaurant owner, who'd conveniently stepped out before the shooting, went off to Europe and came back in June 1932 with his name and address tattooed on his body in case anything happened to him. It did. In September 1932 he was found strangled and stuffed into a sack in an abandoned car, according to the Mob Museum.


Masseria is buried at Old Calvary Cemetery in Queens, alongside a string of other mob names. And here's the strangest bit of all: "Fresh flowers are always placed on his grave," according to the Queens Ledger, and nobody knows who leaves them. Former Genovese capo turned informant Anthony Arillotta tried to find out and got nowhere, though he reckoned it was more likely family than the mob.


Joe the Boss on Screen

Masseria has turned up on screen more than you might expect. Anthony Quinn played him, as Don Masseria, opposite Christian Slater's Lucky Luciano in the 1991 film Mobsters, per IMDb. More recently Ivo Nandi played him in HBO's Boardwalk Empire as a classic old-school Mustache Pete, and Den of Geek praised his slow, careful Sicilian delivery. Both versions lean hard into the image of a greedy old-world boss who couldn't see the new generation coming. That's broadly fair, though as the Miami raid shows, he was happy enough to do business with anyone who made him money.


Why Joe the Boss Still Matters

Masseria's death is the moment the old-style Mafia of the Morellos and the Sicilian bosses gave way to the corporate version run by Luciano and his generation, the world that would later inspire The Godfather. He'd learned his trade alongside men like Frankie Yale and Arnold Rothstein, and the young men who killed him, including Albert Anastasia, would go on to die much the same way.

For a man who spent a decade dodging bullets, it's fitting that the story of his last one is still being argued over nearly a century later.

You Might Also Like

Sources

 
 
bottom of page