The Blonde Tigress: How Eleanor Jarman Vanished, and Why Her Family Might Have Just Found Her Grave
- 1 day ago
- 9 min read
On 23 August 1940, a woman climbed over the fence of the Illinois State Reformatory for Women in Dwight, wearing a polka-dot dress, and hitchhiked away from her 199-year prison sentence. She was never seen again. For more than eighty years, Eleanor Jarman, the woman the Chicago press had nicknamed the Blonde Tigress, was considered one of the longest-sought female fugitives in American history.
In October 2025, a researcher in Denver stood at a grave in Fairmount Cemetery with two women who had travelled from California to see it. They believed the woman buried there, under the name Marie Millman, who had spent decades serving pancakes at a Denver diner and died in 1980 with no known family, was their great-grandmother. The case has never been definitively closed. It might be about to be.
Before Eleanor Jarman / Blonde Tigress: A Hard Start in Iowa
Eleanor Jarman was born Ella Marie Berendt on 22 April 1901 in Sioux City, Iowa, one of twelve children of German immigrant parents, Julius and Amelia Berendt. Three of her siblings died young. The family was poor, and Eleanor left school before she was a teenager, taking work as a waitress at the age of twelve.
In 1920 she married Michael Roy Jarman. They had two sons, LeRoy and LaVerne, and the family moved to Chicago in 1923. Michael began drinking heavily and eventually stopped supporting the household. The couple never officially divorced, but Eleanor was effectively on her own, working as a waitress and a laundress and supplementing her income with government relief payments. During Prohibition she reportedly ran a beer flat, an apartment used to illegally distribute alcohol, which gives some sense of how thin the line was between getting by and breaking the law in her world.
George Dale and the Robbery Crew
Through her various jobs, Eleanor met George Dale, a factory worker who also went by the alias George Kennedy. Dale moved into her apartment at 4300 West Madison Street and became her live-in partner. Dale wanted easier money than factory work provided, and together with a third man, Leo Minneci, a former boxer, they formed a robbery crew.
The roles were simple. Minneci drove the getaway car. Dale, the "gunsel," waved a pistol at the proprietor of whatever small business they'd targeted. Eleanor stood lookout, and according to multiple accounts, was not shy about using a blackjack on victims who didn't move fast enough. Starting in January 1933, the Chicago Tribune ran a series of stories about a crew matching this description robbing small shops across the city. By the time of her arrest, more than fifty robbery victims would identify Eleanor as having been involved.
On 4 August 1933, the crew was reportedly on their way to a Chicago Cubs game when they decided to make one more stop. They robbed a clothing store on West Division Street belonging to 71-year-old Gustav Hoeh. The robbery went wrong. Dale shot Hoeh, who died from his injuries. Eleanor, according to Dale's later testimony, had been carrying the murder weapon in her oversized purse.
Caught with Dyed Hair and Four Pistols
The police moved fast. Officers went to the Madison Street address, but Eleanor and Dale had already fled, taking her two sons with them. A local druggist remembered Eleanor buying blonde hair dye. Neighbours described wild parties at the apartment. The trail led to a second-floor flat at 6232 Drexel Avenue, where on 9 August, five days after the murder, both Eleanor and Dale were arrested. Both had dyed their hair red in an attempt to change their appearance. Under their pillows, police found four pistols and the blackjack.
Within days, Chicago's newspapers had given her a name that would follow her for the rest of her life, however long that turned out to be: the Blonde Tigress. The press leaned hard into the image of a glamorous, dangerous woman, exaggerating her looks and her violence in roughly equal measure, in the way Depression-era tabloids tended to do with any woman involved in violent crime.
Eleanor herself didn't entirely fight the narrative. Asked at trial about the robberies, she said: "It was fun and it was an easy way to get swell clothes and anything you wanted." She also testified that there had been so many robberies that she couldn't recall any particular one standing out. She maintained throughout that she hadn't known Dale and Minneci were planning to rob Hoeh's store specifically, and that she certainly hadn't known anyone would be shot.
Eleven Days From Murder to Sentencing
The speed of the legal process is one of the most striking things about the case by modern standards. Hoeh was murdered on 4 August. The trio were arrested on 9 August. They were arraigned on 17 August. The trial began on 28 August, just eleven days later. By 1 September 1933, less than a month after the murder, Eleanor Jarman, George Dale, and Leo Minneci had all been convicted.
Dale, as the man who had pulled the trigger, was sentenced to death. He was executed the following year. Jarman and Minneci, convicted as accomplices, each received 199 years. Eleanor was sent to the Illinois State Reformatory for Women in Dwight to begin serving what was, on paper, effectively a life sentence.
Her time there appears to have been, by the standards of the institution, a success. The reformatory's stated mission was to return "unfortunate girls and women to society, clean, healthful, and with character reconstructed." Whatever Eleanor's internal state, she served seven years without apparent incident.
Over the Fence in a Polka-Dot Dress
On 23 August 1940, seven years into her sentence, Eleanor Jarman escaped from Dwight with a fellow inmate. She scaled a fence and hitchhiked away wearing a polka-dot dress. She was never recaptured.
The manhunt that followed was sustained and, by the standards of the era, remarkably long. Wanted posters circulated with her description and fingerprints as late as 1953, twenty years after her conviction. In 1951, the Chicago Tribune dubbed her "the most dangerous woman alive," still describing an escaped convict who, by then, had been free for over a decade. She is considered among the longest-sought female fugitives in American criminal history.
And then, nothing. No arrest, no sighting, no further trace, for decades. For another case of a fugitive who managed to simply disappear into ordinary life, read about Big Nose George and the strange afterlife of an outlaw, a very different kind of vanishing act from the same era of American crime.
A Grandson's Letter and a Researcher's Theory
The case might have remained permanently unresolved if not for Eleanor's own family. Her grandson, Doug Jarman, pursued a clemency petition decades later, arguing that since his grandmother hadn't been arrested again in all the years since her escape, she must have rehabilitated herself, wherever she was. The petition turned on that logic: an escaped prisoner who had gone fifty years without reoffending had, in effect, served her sentence in her own way.
Doug Jarman told the Chicago Tribune he had once received a letter from someone claiming to be his grandmother, asking for money for medical treatment. He believed it might be genuine, since it had been sent to an address of his that wasn't publicly available. He also said his grandfather, LeRoy, had told him Eleanor used the alias "Marie Mellman" or "Millman." Doug Jarman died before the mystery was resolved, but that detail, a half-remembered alias passed down through the family, became the thread that researcher Silvia Pettem eventually pulled.
Pettem, a longtime Colorado author and researcher with more than twenty books to her name, took up the case after Doug Jarman's death. She started with genealogical databases, searching for women named Marie Millman who fit Eleanor's profile and timeframe. She then eliminated every candidate who, according to census records and obituaries, had documented parents, siblings, or children. Only one Marie Millman was left.
Marie Millman of East Colfax Avenue
That Marie Millman appeared in Denver records beginning in 1951, the same year Eleanor Jarman's wanted posters were still circulating. She worked as a waitress at restaurants along East Colfax Avenue for over twenty years, including a diner called the Kitchen, now Pete's Kitchen, as well as Super Chef and Sam's Cafe. She died in 1980 and was buried in Plot 67 of Fairmount Cemetery in Denver's Windsor neighbourhood. Denver probate records list her as having died intestate, with no known heirs.
Pettem described what she found in blunt terms: there was no birth record for this Marie Millman, no record of her having parents, no record of her existing at all before 1951. "It's like she wasn't ever born," Pettem said. For a woman who needed to disappear in 1940, that's exactly what you'd expect to find eleven years later under a new name.
The circumstantial case is genuinely compelling, even if it isn't proof. Eleanor had worked as a waitress since she was twelve years old and continued doing so right up until her crime spree. Waitressing pays in cash, which leaves no paper trail, an obviously attractive trait for someone evading a 199-year sentence. The alias "Marie" was Eleanor's own middle name. And the timing lines up: Marie Millman's recorded life in Denver begins in 1951, eleven years after Eleanor went over the fence at Dwight, plenty of time to put real distance, geographical and otherwise, between herself and Illinois.
Pettem published her findings in 2023 in In Search of the Blonde Tigress: The Untold Story of Eleanor Jarman. She has been candid that the evidence is circumstantial. Some reviewers have noted the case rests on a shared nickname, a shared profession, and an absence of records, rather than anything more concrete. Pettem herself puts her confidence at "99.9 percent," while acknowledging that the final fraction matters.
The Family Comes to Denver
What happened next is the part of the story that almost never happens in cases like this. Eleanor Jarman's granddaughter and great-granddaughter read Pettem's research and got in touch with her. They believed she had found their relative. In the summer of 2024, the two women travelled from California to Denver, and Pettem took them to Fairmount Cemetery to see Marie Millman's grave, and to Pete's Kitchen, where Eleanor may have spent two decades pouring coffee and serving breakfast to people who had no idea who she was.
To confirm the identification beyond reasonable doubt would require exhuming Millman's remains and running forensic genealogy DNA analysis against Eleanor's known descendants. But Millman died with no recorded family, which means there's nobody with the legal standing to authorise an exhumation, and a judge is unlikely to order one for a death that wasn't a crime. Pettem has said she doubts a court would grant the warrant needed. For now, the case sits exactly where it has sat for years: 99.9 percent resolved, and permanently, perhaps, just short of that.
Pettem's hope is that someone who knew Marie Millman during her decades on Colfax Avenue, a former co-worker, a regular customer, anyone with a photograph or a memory, might come forward with something that could close the gap. "I keep hoping that she got some good out of life," wrote one columnist who covered her disappearance decades ago, addressing Eleanor directly. "Goodnight, Eleanor Jarman, wherever you are."
What the Case Says
There's something almost unbearably ordinary about the ending Pettem has proposed for one of the most sensationalised criminals of the 1930s. The Blonde Tigress, the most dangerous woman alive, the subject of two-decade manhunts and circulating wanted posters, simply went back to being a waitress. She served food on Colfax Avenue for over twenty years, presumably to people who passed through Denver without a second thought, and then she died, alone, with no family on record, and was buried under a name that may or may not have been entirely invented.
If Pettem is right, Eleanor Jarman effectively served her own sentence: not 199 years in Dwight, but forty years as someone else, hiding in plain sight in a diner a few blocks off a major American avenue. The reformatory's mission had been to return women to society "clean, healthful, and with character reconstructed." Eleanor never gave them the chance to claim credit for it, but if Marie Millman really was Eleanor Jarman, she may have done exactly that, just on her own terms, and without anyone watching.
For another case where a person of considerable notoriety vanished and the question of what became of them was never fully resolved, read about the disappearance of Lord Lucan, and the murder, gambling debts, and aristocracy behind it.
SOURCES
1. Denver Westword: Was a Denver Waitress This "Dangerous" 1940 Illinois Prison Escapee? — https://www.westword.com/news/denver-waitress-may-have-been-chicago-fugitive-24533181/
2. Denverite: Has the Notorious "Blonde Tigress" Finally Been Found in Denver? — https://denverite.com/2025/10/30/blonde-tigress-grave/
3. The Colorado Sun: A Daring Escape Sends Authorities "In Search of the Blonde Tigress" — https://coloradosun.com/2023/09/24/sunlit-in-search-of-the-blonde-tigress-silvia-pettem/
4. The Colorado Sun: Cemetery Reenactment Hooked Silvia Pettem on Tracking Missing Persons — https://coloradosun.com/2023/09/24/sunlit-silvia-pettem-in-search-of-the-blonde-tigress/
5. Yahoo News / Chicago Tribune: The Capture of the "Blonde Tigress" Captivated Chicagoans in 1933. Then She Vanished — https://www.yahoo.com/news/capture-blonde-tigress-captivated-chicagoans-100000585.html
6. State Stories: How Eleanor Jarman Served 7 Years of a 199-Year Murder Sentence, Escaped an Illinois Prison in 1940, and Was Never Found — https://statestories.com/how-eleanor-jarman-served-7-years-of-a-199-year-murder-sentence-escaped-an-illinois-prison-in-1940-and-was-never-found/
7. Silvia Pettem, In Search of the Blonde Tigress: The Untold Story of Eleanor Jarman (Globe Pequot, 2023)
