top of page

Dr Crippen And The Murder Of Cora Crippen

Jan 31, 2024
15 min read

Updated: Nov 1


Dr. Crippen portrait, 'MURDER AND MUTILATION' headline, police investigation scene.

On the night of 31 January 1910, a music hall singer called Cora Crippen waved off her last dinner guests from a tall house in Holloway, north London. Nobody ever saw her again. Six months later her husband, a mild little American doctor with gold spectacles and a sandy moustache, was on the run across the Atlantic with his secretary dressed as a boy, a ship's captain was tapping out his description over the wireless and half the world was reading about it over breakfast. Dr Hawley Harvey Crippen was hanged that November. More than a century on, a DNA test has some people convinced the body in his cellar wasn't even his wife's.

Quick answers

•       Who was Dr Crippen? An American homeopath and patent medicine seller living in London, hanged at Pentonville on 23 November 1910 for murdering his wife.

•       Who was Cora Crippen? Born Kunigunde Mackamotzki in Brooklyn in 1873, she performed as Belle Elmore and was treasurer of the Music Hall Ladies' Guild.

•       How was he caught? The captain of the SS Montrose recognised him and sent a wireless message. It's widely described as the first time wireless was used to catch a fugitive.

•       Was Crippen innocent? A 2007 DNA study found the cellar remains didn't match Cora's female-line relatives, but the work rests on one century-old slide and plenty of experts still think he did it.

•       What happened to Ethel Le Neve? She was acquitted, changed her name, married an accountant in Croydon and kept her past from her family until she died in 1967.

A homeopath from Coldwater, Michigan

Crippen was born in 1862 in Coldwater, Michigan, and trained in homeopathy before setting up as a physician in New York. That's the respectable version. Historian Hallie Rubenhold's 2025 book Story of a Murder paints something darker. Reviewing it for The Spectator, Lisa Hilton picks out Rubenhold's portrait of a man drawn more and more to gynaecology, who drifted from one dodgy venture to the next and eventually settled on selling cures for deafness.


Dr Crippen
Dr Crippen

He'd also been married before. His first wife, Charlotte Bell, died aged 33, officially of a stroke. Shortly before she died, she'd written to her brother that her husband was about to operate on her again. Nothing was ever proved, but it's an uncomfortable detail that almost every retelling of the Crippen case leaves out.


Kunigunde Mackamotzki becomes Belle Elmore

Cora was born in Brooklyn in 1873. Rubenhold found that when she met Crippen in 1892 she was working as a maid and was pregnant by her employer. Crippen helped arrange an abortion, married her and later talked her into having her ovaries removed, an operation she bitterly regretted. That surgery left a scar on her abdomen, and that scar would end up at the centre of a murder trial.


Cora Crippen, stage name Belle Elmore, posing in an ornate gown and feathered headdress in an early 1900s black and white publicity photo
Cora Crippen, who performed as Belle Elmore

The couple moved to London in 1897, when Crippen took a job running the British office of the patent medicine firm Munyon's. Cora threw herself into the music halls as Belle Elmore. By most accounts she wasn't much of a singer.


The music hall blog Into the Limelight describes her as a sometime male impersonator and would-be opera star, and records that during the 1907 music hall strike she crossed the picket line, with Marie Lloyd herself reportedly telling the strikers to let her through. What Belle lacked in talent she made up for in personality. She was loud, generous and fond of furs and diamonds. She became the honorary treasurer of the Music Hall Ladies' Guild, a charity run by performers' wives and actresses.



Ethel Le Neve and 39 Hilldrop Crescent

After Munyon's sacked him, Crippen bounced around the patent medicine trade and ended up at the Drouet Institute for the Deaf. There he met Ethel Le Neve, a typist born in Norfolk in 1883. She became his secretary and, by around 1905, his lover.


Ethel Le Neve
Ethel Le Neve

In September 1905 the Crippens took the lease on 39 Hilldrop Crescent, a big semi-detached house off Camden Road in Holloway. Money was tight, so they took in lodgers, and Belle had an affair with at least one of them. It wasn't a happy home. Holloway would later become even better known for its women's prison, where Ruth Ellis became the last woman hanged in Britain in 1955.


The last dinner party

On 31 January 1910 the Crippens had two old friends round for dinner and cards: Paul and Clara Martinetti, retired music hall performers. The Martinettis left at about 1am on 1 February. They were the last people, other than her husband, known to have seen Belle alive.



Twelve days earlier, on 19 January, Crippen had walked into the chemists Lewis & Burrows on New Oxford Street and bought five grains of hyoscine hydrobromide, signing the poison book for it. Hyoscine, also called scopolamine, was used at the time as a sedative. As chemist Simon Cotton explains in the University of Bristol's Molecule of the Month, in the right doses it produces a kind of twilight sleep, which is why it was later tried as a truth serum. In larger doses it kills. The man who appeared at the trial on behalf of Lewis & Burrows was William James Spratling, a chemist turned barrister who'd been the first headmaster of Haberdashers' Aske's school in New Cross. He's buried in Ladywell Cemetery in south-east London, under a headstone that's usually hidden in the shrubbery.


The story starts to fall apart

Belle's friends at the Guild noticed she was gone almost immediately. Ethel turned up with a letter, supposedly from Belle, resigning as treasurer because she'd been called away to America. Then Crippen told people she'd fallen ill there, and then that she'd died. Meanwhile Ethel moved into Hilldrop Crescent, and at a music hall charity ball that February she turned up wearing a diamond brooch Belle's friends instantly recognised.


39 Hilldrop Crescent
39 Hilldrop Crescent

That was too much for Lil Hawthorne, a music hall star and Guild member, and her husband and manager John Nash. When they got back from a tour of America and heard the story, Nash tried and failed to find out where Belle had died or been cremated. He then went to see Crippen in person and came away so uneasy that he took a taxi straight to Scotland Yard. Both of them later gave evidence at the trial, and the Treasury paid them £100 in 1911 to cover their lost earnings.


On 8 July 1910 Chief Inspector Walter Dew went to see Crippen at his office. Crippen calmly admitted the death story was a lie. Belle, he said, had run off to America with another man, a music hall performer named Bruce Miller, and he'd made up the death to save face. Dew had a look round the house, found nothing and left more or less satisfied. Crippen panicked anyway. The next day he shaved off his moustache, and he and Ethel, dressed as a boy, slipped out of the country to Brussels.


What was under the cellar floor

When Dew came back and found the couple gone, he went back to Hilldrop Crescent with a team and started digging. Under the brick floor of the coal cellar they found a mass of human flesh, wrapped in part of a man's pyjama jacket, sprinkled with lime and buried in clay. There was no head, no limbs and no skeleton. Police dug up the garden too, but the rest of the body was never found.

Among the remains was a Hinde's hair curler with a tuft of bleached blonde hair still wound into it. Belle had dyed her hair blonde. Pathologists later found hyoscine in the organs. And the pyjama top turned out to be the most important clue of all, though nobody realised it straight away.


The cellar at 39 Hilldrop Crescent
The cellar at 39 Hilldrop Crescent

The jacket carried the label of Jones Brothers, a department store on Holloway Road. James Chilvers, the shop's menswear buyer, was able to tell the court that the label read Jones Bros (Holloway) Ltd, a name the company only started using after it became a limited company in 1906. Even better, he produced a sales record showing a pair of pyjamas bought in the January 1909 sale. John Lewis's own company archive, which later took over Jones Brothers, still calls Chilvers' evidence the turning point of the case. It mattered because Crippen's whole defence was that the remains must have been buried before he moved in. Pyjamas made after 1906 couldn't have been there before 1905.


Mr and Master Robinson

On 20 July Crippen and Ethel boarded the Canadian Pacific liner SS Montrose at Antwerp, bound for Quebec. He called himself John Robinson. Ethel was his son. It was a terrible disguise. Captain Henry Kendall noticed that the boy's trousers were roughly mended, that his hips swayed in a way no teenage lad's did and that the hair poking out from under his hat was far too soft. Kendall had the newspaper photos of the London cellar murderer on board and compared them with Mr Robinson, who had no moustache but otherwise looked an awful lot like Crippen. By one account, Crippen spent the voyage reading Edgar Wallace's thriller The Four Just Men.


On 22 July, with the ship about 120 miles west of Cornwall, Kendall had his wireless operator send a message that became famous. It began: "Have strong suspicion that Crippen London cellar murderer and accomplice are among saloon passengers." It went on to say the moustache was gone, a beard was growing and the accomplice was dressed as a boy. Dew raced to Liverpool and boarded the White Star Line's faster Laurentic, which overtook the Montrose in the middle of the Atlantic.


Here's the strange part. Because of the wireless, the world knew exactly where Crippen was, but Crippen had no idea. A local history of the arrest written for the Quebec journal L'Estuaire explains that Kendall was sending daily dispatches to the Montreal Star, which were relayed to the Daily Mail in London. Readers could follow the fugitives' meals and deck walks while the fugitives themselves sat in the saloon thinking they'd got away with it.


It's worth remembering how new all this was. Ship-to-shore wireless was barely a decade old. Two years later the same technology would bring the Carpathia racing to the survivors of the Titanic.


The arrest at Father Point

The Laurentic reached Father Point (Pointe-au-Père), near Rimouski on the St Lawrence, ahead of the Montrose. By then the tiny place was overrun. Jean Marcoux's account for L'Estuaire says about 2,000 locals turned out, and roughly fifty journalists had arrived from across Canada and the big American cities. Dew borrowed the uniform of a local pilot called Gaudreault, was rowed out from the pilot boat Eureka with four sailors and climbed aboard the Montrose on the morning of 31 July 1910 in steady rain.


Dr Crippen, wearing a hat, being escorted down a ship's wooden gangway by detectives and officials after his arrest in Canada in July 1910
Crippen, hidden beneath a hat and high collar, being escorted off the Montrose by Chief Inspector Dew.

He walked up to the man calling himself Robinson and greeted him by his real name. Crippen, by most accounts, seemed almost relieved. Ethel is said to have fainted. Only once the arrests were done did the ship's whistle sound and the Eureka come alongside, at which point the press pack charged on board. The local wireless operator, John McWilliams, had spent the night before with Dew relaying messages to the ship. Four years later, McWilliams would be the man who picked up the SOS from the Empress of Ireland.



The trial at the Old Bailey

Crippen went on trial at the Old Bailey on 18 October 1910 before the Lord Chief Justice, Lord Alverstone. The prosecution was led by Richard Muir. The original depositions are still held at The National Archives in Kew, under the reference CRIM 1/117.


His defence was a mess from the start. As retired solicitor James Morton tells it in the Law Society Gazette, the flashy solicitor Arthur Newton wired Crippen offering his services and then tried to brief Edward Marshall Hall, the most famous defence barrister of the day. Hall's clerk wanted "cheque with the brief", the money never appeared and Newton briefed the much less able Alfred Tobin instead. Marshall Hall, who'd later win Marguerite Alibert's sensational acquittal in 1923, always said he'd have argued manslaughter: that Crippen gave Belle hyoscine as a sedative to keep her out of the way while he was with Ethel, and accidentally killed her.


Ethel Le Neve, in a wide hat with a veil, stood in the dock beside Dr Crippen during court proceedings in London in 1910
Crippen and Ethel Le Neve in the dock together in 1910. They were later tried separately at the Old Bailey

Instead Crippen stuck to his story that he knew nothing about the remains. That meant taking on the scientists, and he lost. A young pathologist called Bernard Spilsbury showed the jury a piece of skin he said carried a scar matching Belle's old operation. Defence experts argued it was just a fold of skin, partly because it seemed to contain hair follicles, which shouldn't appear in a scar. The Home Office analyst William Willcox told the court he'd found hyoscine in the organs. And then came Chilvers and his pyjamas.


The jury took 27 minutes to find Crippen guilty. Crippen still protested his innocence as he was sentenced to death.


Pentonville, 23 November 1910

Crippen's appeal failed and the Home Secretary, a 35-year-old Winston Churchill, refused a reprieve. He was hanged at Pentonville Prison at 9am on 23 November 1910 by John Ellis and William Willis, two of the jobbing hangmen who came before the Pierrepoint era (if you want the full story of that grim trade, here's our piece on Albert Pierrepoint). Crippen was 48. Thirteen years later the same two men hanged Edith Thompson and Frederick Bywaters at exactly the same moment, Ellis at Holloway and Willis at Pentonville.


His last request was that a photograph of Ethel and some of her letters be buried with him. It was granted, and he went into an unmarked grave in the prison grounds with them. He also left her everything he had.


Even his death got exploited. His solicitor Arthur Newton claimed he'd got a death-cell confession out of Crippen and sold it to the Evening Times. It was a fake, the paper's circulation collapsed when that came out and Newton was eventually suspended by the Law Society. And in 2025 Crippen's own pocket-sized Book of Common Prayer, signed in pencil with his Hilldrop Crescent address, was put up for auction by Richard Winterton Auctioneers with an estimate of £250 to £350.


What happened to everyone else

Ethel sailed for Toronto in 1911 and worked there as a secretary for about five years before homesickness brought her back to London in 1916. She took the surname Nelson, married an accountant from Croydon called Stanley Smith and had a son and a daughter. Her husband, who people said looked a little like Crippen, died young without ever knowing who she'd been. In 1954 the novelist Ursula Bloom tracked her down hoping to write her story. Over tea, Bloom asked whether she'd marry Crippen again if he came back. Ethel said she would. She died in 1967.


Walter Dew retired from Scotland Yard at 47, just weeks before the hanging. He'd been a young detective in Whitechapel in 1888 and was at the scene of Mary Jane Kelly's murder, the last of the canonical victims of the man the papers called Jack the Ripper (we've written about the women he killed too). His memoir, I Caught Crippen, came out in 1938, and he died in Worthing in 1947.



Captain Kendall became a celebrity. Four years later, in May 1914, he was in command of the Empress of Ireland when she was rammed by a coal ship off Father Point, almost exactly where he'd handed Crippen over. The liner went down in around 14 minutes and 1,012 people died. Kendall survived. The crew of the pilot boat Eureka, the same boat that had carried Dew out to the Montrose, pulled around 150 survivors from the water, Kendall among them. The Montrose herself was wrecked near Dover later that year.


The house on Hilldrop Crescent stood mostly empty for decades. A Scottish comedian's attempt to turn it into a Crippen museum went nowhere, and it was destroyed by German bombs in the Second World War. The site was swallowed up by the Hilldrop Estate, which aerial photos show under construction in 1947.


The DNA bombshell

For nearly a century Crippen was the textbook wife murderer, with his own waxwork in Madame Tussauds' Chamber of Horrors. Then in October 2007 a team from Michigan State University announced that the remains weren't Cora's.


Forensic biologist David Foran borrowed one of Spilsbury's original microscope slides from the Royal London Hospital's archives. As The Scientist reported, he spent around six months on it, chipping away the glued cover slip with a scalpel and pulling mitochondrial DNA out of a few millimetres of tissue. Mitochondrial DNA passes down the female line, so genealogist Beth Wills spent years combing through birth, marriage, census and immigration records to find living relatives descended from Cora's maternal half-sister. She found two grandnieces and a great-grandniece.

The torso skin bearing the supposed 'scar'
The torso skin bearing the supposed 'scar'

The relatives matched each other. They didn't match the slide. Foran told the Camden New Journal: "We know that the remains Spilsbury worked on were not Cora's." Later tests on the Y chromosome went further and suggested the tissue came from a man. The team published its findings in the Journal of Forensic Sciences, and toxicologist John Trestrail, who worked alongside Foran, came out in favour of a pardon. He pointed out that poisoners almost never cut up their victims, noting that his database of around 1,100 poisoning cases contained only one dismemberment.


If it wasn't Belle, who was it? Trestrail floated the idea that Crippen may have been doing backstreet abortions and that the remains belonged to a patient, though there's no hard evidence for that. Others went further and suggested the police planted the remains, an idea that Lansing City Pulse points out runs into one big problem: the real Cora was still missing, and nobody has ever found her alive. Wills did turn up some intriguing leads in the 1920 US census, but they've never been confirmed.


Why plenty of people still think he did it

The DNA work has had a rough ride. Writing in The Times, David Aaronovitch picked holes in it, pointing out that the male result came from a very new technique used only by this one team, applied to a single slide that Foran himself had described as less than ideal. A slide that's sat in a hospital archive for a hundred years, been handled by who knows how many people and may or may not be the exact one Spilsbury used is a shaky foundation for overturning a conviction. Foran stood by the results, saying repeated tests gave the same answer and that the first extraction attempt yielding nothing argued against contamination.


Then there's everything else. Crippen bought a lethal dose of hyoscine less than a fortnight before his wife vanished. Hyoscine was found in the remains. He told a string of lies about where she'd gone, forged her letters, gave her jewellery to his mistress and fled the country in disguise the moment police showed an interest. The pyjamas were bought after the Crippens moved in. Rubenhold looked hard at the claims that the body wasn't Belle's and, as the Budapest Times noted in its review, came down firmly against them.


Patrick Crippen, a distant American relative, applied for a posthumous pardon through the Criminal Cases Review Commission and asked for the doctor's remains to be sent home to the family plot in the US. The bid failed in December 2009.


So the cellar still keeps its secret. Either the DNA is wrong and Crippen was exactly the killer the jury thought he was, or someone else was buried under that floor and Belle Elmore vanished so completely that no one has found her in 116 years. Britain has certainly hanged the wrong man before. Just look at Timothy Evans and 10 Rillington Place. But for now, the evidence pointing at Crippen is still a lot heavier than the single slide pointing away from him.

Further reading

If you want to go deeper into the case, these two are the best places to start:

•       Story of a Murder: The Wives, the Mistress and Dr Crippen by Hallie Rubenhold: The author of The Five puts Belle Elmore, Charlotte Bell and Ethel Le Neve at the centre of the story for the first time.

•       Thunderstruck by Erik Larson: Weaves the Crippen manhunt together with Guglielmo Marconi's race to perfect wireless, the technology that caught him.

As an Amazon Associate, Utterly Interesting earns from qualifying purchases.

You might also like

Sources





 
 
bottom of page