Dena Schlosser: The Plano Mother Who Believed God Wanted Her Baby

On the morning of 22 November 2004, police officers walked into a small apartment in Plano, a well-off suburb north of Dallas, and found a 35-year-old woman sitting in her living room covered in blood with a knife still in her hand. Hymns were playing. In a back bedroom lay her 10-month-old daughter, Margaret, whose arms had been cut off. The baby died shortly afterwards.
The woman was Dena Schlosser, and her case would become one of the most disturbing in modern Texas history. It wasn't just the horror of what happened. It was everything that led up to it: an untreated psychotic illness, a family with no money and no health insurance, a child welfare investigation that closed months too early and a fringe preacher who taught that mental illness was the work of demons. Here's the full story, including what happened to Dena after the courts were done with her.
Quick Answers
Who is Dena Schlosser? A former Plano, Texas mother who killed her 10-month-old daughter Margaret in November 2004 while suffering from severe postpartum psychosis.
What happened to Margaret Schlosser? Her mother cut off both of her arms with a kitchen knife. She was taken to hospital but couldn't be saved.
Was Dena Schlosser convicted? No. Her first trial ended in a hung jury in February 2006, and in April 2006 a judge found her not guilty by reason of insanity.
Where is Dena Schlosser now? She was released to outpatient care in 2008, recommitted to a state hospital after an episode in 2010 and was last publicly reported working at a Walmart in 2012 before being fired once she was recognised.

A Family Under Pressure
Dena and her husband John moved to Texas around 1999 with their first daughter. On paper they looked like any other young suburban family, but the cracks showed early. John lost his job not long after they arrived and started working for himself as a consultant. Money was tight. By the time Margaret, nicknamed Maggie, was born in January 2004, the family had no health insurance at all, which is why a midwife delivered the baby instead of a hospital team.
The Schlossers now had three girls. The older two were nine and six. Dena was also carrying the weight of her mother Connie's Parkinson's disease from a distance. Connie lived in Canada with Dena's stepfather Mick Macaulay, who worked as a mental health counsellor. Dena phoned her almost every day.
Then things started to go badly wrong. In the weeks after Maggie's birth, Dena was diagnosed with postpartum psychosis, a rare and serious condition that can bring on hallucinations, delusions and a complete break from reality. It's a psychiatric emergency, and without treatment it can be fatal for mother or child.
The Warning Signs Everyone Saw
Here's the part of the story that still makes people angry. In January 2004, Texas Child Protective Services opened a neglect investigation into Dena after she wandered off and left newborn Maggie alone at home. Her five-year-old daughter was spotted pedalling down the street on a bicycle, chasing after her mum.
Dena was put into psychiatric treatment and the investigation stayed open for months. In August 2004, CPS decided she was stable and closed the case. It was a fateful call. In the four months between that decision and Maggie's death, Dena took no medication and saw no doctor.
Why would a woman with a diagnosed psychotic illness stop treatment? The answer, at least in part, lay in the church the family had thrown themselves into.

Doyle Davidson and the Water of Life Church
The Schlossers worshipped at Water of Life Ministries, a small charismatic church in Plano run by Doyle Davidson. He wasn't your typical pastor. A former veterinarian in his seventies, Davidson described himself as an apostle and a prophet and claimed God personally told him to start the church back in the early 1980s.
His sermons were fire and brimstone, built on a strictly literal reading of the Bible. He dismissed mainstream Methodist, Catholic and Baptist churches as cults. He preached that women carried a rebellious "Jezebel spirit" and needed to submit to their husbands. And crucially, he taught that mental illness was demonic and should be fought with prayer, not pills.
Dena's family could see where this was heading. Her stepfather later told reporters he blamed mental illness for what happened but believed Davidson's teachings played a part too. The family had listened to around 60 hours of Davidson's online sermons and were horrified by the violent imagery in them. Two years before Maggie's death, during a family visit, Davidson had laid hands on Dena's mother to drive out the spirits causing her Parkinson's. Afterwards, Connie's medication was thrown out because Dena was convinced she'd been cured.
Davidson brushed the criticism off. "I only teach what's in the Bible, and that's what makes them mad," he told the press. A 2006 piece by journalist Paul Kix, later picked as one of D Magazine's 40 greatest stories, painted a picture of a domineering man whose influence may well have made Dena's illness worse. It also revealed that Davidson had carried on a long affair with a married church member, which he described as a "marriage".
By the summer of 2004, Dena's involvement with the church had ramped up sharply.
22 November 2004
By November, Dena's untreated illness had taken over completely. She'd become convinced that God wanted both her and her baby to go to heaven.
On the morning of 22 November, with Christian music playing through the apartment, she took a nine-inch knife from the kitchen and cut off Maggie's arms. Officers found Maggie lying in her crib in a back bedroom. She was rushed to hospital and pronounced dead.
The two older girls weren't physically hurt. John later filed for divorce and was given custody of both of them.
Dena was charged with capital murder. In Texas, that's a charge that can carry the death penalty, though prosecutors eventually sought a life sentence instead.

The Trials: Was Dena Schlosser Insane?
Nobody seriously disputed what Dena had done. The whole case came down to one question: did she know it was wrong? Under Texas law, that's the test for insanity. A defendant can be wildly mentally ill and still be convicted if the jury thinks they understood their act was wrong at the time.
Dena pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity, and her trial opened in Collin County in early 2006. Her lawyer, David Haynes, wanted her sent to a state psychiatric hospital. Prosecutors urged the jury to hold her accountable and asked for life behind bars, arguing she'd known exactly what she was doing.
After four days of deliberations in February 2006, the jury couldn't agree. Ten jurors believed she was insane, one thought she was guilty and one couldn't make up their mind. The judge declared a mistrial.
Rather than put everyone through the whole thing again, both sides agreed to let Judge Chris Oldner decide the retrial alone, based on the evidence from the first trial. On 7 April 2006, after a brief hearing in McKinney where both sides skipped closing arguments, Oldner found Dena not guilty by reason of insanity. He didn't explain his reasoning.
Dena said nothing as bailiffs led her away. Haynes told reporters she'd wanted to go to hospital because "she feels it is her best chance to get better." Her former stepfather Bob Nicholas, the only relative in court that day, called the verdict the best outcome anyone could have hoped for.
Texas was getting used to cases like this. Andrea Yates had drowned her five children in Houston in 2001, and in 2004 a jury in East Texas acquitted Deanna Laney on grounds of insanity after she stoned two of her sons to death. All three women had acted under religious delusions. If you want to see how religious fervour can twist into something deadly in a family setting, the case of Marcus Wesson is another grim example. And McKinney's courthouse was no stranger to headline murder trials, having hosted the Candy Montgomery axe murder trial back in 1980.
Roommates With Andrea Yates
After the verdict, Dena was committed to the North Texas State Hospital in Vernon, a high-security facility about 174 miles north-west of Dallas. Patients on its Maple unit were almost entirely cut off from the outside world.
In the summer of 2006, a new patient arrived on the ward. It was Andrea Yates, freshly acquitted at her own retrial. The two women ended up as roommates and, remarkably, as friends. The Dallas Morning News reported that they bonded over their shared experience, talking through their memories and trying to make sense of their illnesses.
Andrea's ex-husband Rusty still visited her and said Dena had become a genuine friend. "Hopefully, they can help each other through the long recovery process," he said. Andrea was moved to a lower-security hospital in Kerrville in January 2007, so the friendship on the ward didn't last long.
Meanwhile, Dena's family life was gone for good. The divorce was finalised in 2007, and the decree barred her from any contact with her two surviving daughters. She hadn't spoken to John since he visited her in custody shortly after her arrest.
Release, Relapse and a Job at Walmart
Dena was later moved to Rusk State Hospital, and in November 2008, just four years after Maggie's death, Judge Oldner ruled she could be released into outpatient treatment. The conditions were strict. She had to keep taking her medication, attend weekly mental health appointments, stay on doctor-supervised birth control and never be left alone with children.
It didn't last. In March 2010, firefighters in Richardson found her wandering down the street at 2am. Haynes said she'd stuck to her outpatient rules until recently, but Oldner revoked her freedom and ordered her back to Terrell State Hospital. Because she'd never been convicted of a crime, this was a civil commitment rather than a prison sentence, and there was no fixed end date.

She was eventually released again, and by June 2012 she was working as a checker at the Walmart in Terrell, east of Dallas. She'd passed the store's criminal background check, which makes sense, as she'd never actually been convicted of anything. She was also using a different surname by then.
That all fell apart in August 2012, when a customer recognised her and tipped off Dallas TV station WFAA. As soon as the station called the store asking questions, Walmart fired her. The story aired after she'd already lost the job.
The sacking split opinion. Plenty of people were outraged that a woman who'd killed her baby was out serving the public at all. Others, including a Dallas Observer columnist, argued that hounding a recovering psychiatric patient out of work made nobody safer. Mental health experts warned that losing the job could seriously damage her recovery as she tried to rebuild some kind of life.
Who Was Really to Blame?
Two decades on, the Dena Schlosser case still raises awkward questions, and most of them aren't really about Dena at all.
There's the CPS investigation that closed in August 2004, three months before Maggie died. There's the lack of health insurance that left a family with a seriously ill mother unable to afford proper care. There's a church that told a woman with a psychotic illness that prayer would do more for her than medication. And there's Doyle Davidson himself, who never faced any legal consequences and carried on preaching against the "Jezebel spirit" for years.
None of that brings Maggie back. But it does go some way to explaining how a woman with no history of violence ended up doing something so unthinkable to the child she'd carried. Postpartum psychosis affects roughly one or two in every thousand new mothers. It's treatable, and most women recover fully. In Dena's case, almost every safety net that should have caught her failed.
Suggested Reading
If this case has left you wanting to understand more about postpartum psychosis and mothers who kill, these are worth picking up.
Are You There Alone? The Unspeakable Crime of Andrea Yates by Suzanne O'Malley. The go-to account of the case against Andrea Yates, who'd later share a hospital room with Dena. It's also a sharp look at how Texas handles mental illness in its courts.
Mothers Who Kill Their Children by Cheryl L. Meyer and Michelle Oberman. A thoughtful study of why some mothers end up harming their children, from neglect to psychosis.
Infanticide: Psychosocial and Legal Perspectives on Mothers Who Kill by Margaret G. Spinelli. A more academic read, but brilliant on how postpartum psychosis works and why the law struggles with it.
As an Amazon Associate, Utterly Interesting earns from qualifying purchases.
You Might Also Like
Sources
D Magazine's 40 Greatest Stories: The Devil, Doyle Davidson, and Dena Schlosser, D Magazine
Pastor's influence criticized in slaying, HeraldNet
Mistrial in baby slaying case, CBS News
Mistrial in baby killing, The Week
Mom avoids prison in baby slay case, CBS News
Woman tried for severing baby's arms found not guilty by insanity, Fox News
'We talk about our memories': Child-killers Dena Schlosser, Andrea Yates find solace in friendship, The Dallas Morning News
2 moms who killed children form friendship, Deseret News
Plano mother who cut baby's arms off ordered back into state mental hospital, WFAA
Schlosser found working at Terrell Walmart, CBS Texas
Dena Schlosser lands job at Walmart, gets fired, D Magazine
Dena Schlosser, the Plano baby chopper, is outed then fired from Walmart. Now what?, Dallas Observer
Experts: Job loss a blow to Plano mother who severed baby's arms, The Dallas Morning News





















































































