top of page

The Murder of Dr Barnett Slepian: The Sniper, the Hit List and the Hunt for James Kopp

Jun 20, 2025
10 min read

Updated: Oct 23

Composite of Dr Barnett Slepian in glasses and a suit, mourners laying flowers at a clinic door and the FBI wanted poster for James Kopp

On the evening of Friday 23 October 1998, Dr Barnett Slepian got home from synagogue, walked into his kitchen in Amherst, a suburb of Buffalo, and started warming up some soup. A few seconds later a rifle bullet came through the back window. His wife and four sons were in the house. Within hours, someone had put a line through his name on an anti-abortion website that listed doctors as targets.


It was the fifth sniper attack on an abortion provider in upstate New York and Canada in four years, and the first one to kill. The man who pulled the trigger spent two and a half years on the run across three countries before a parcel of cash gave him away at a small post office in Brittany.

Quick Answers

  • Who was Barnett Slepian? A 52-year-old obstetrician and gynaecologist from Amherst, New York, who provided abortions at a clinic in Buffalo.

  • When was he killed? On Friday 23 October 1998, by a single rifle shot fired through his kitchen window from the woods behind his house.

  • Who killed him? James Charles Kopp, an anti-abortion militant known in the movement as "Atomic Dog". He confessed to firing the shot in 2002.

  • How was Kopp caught? A paid FBI informant's tip led French police to Dinan in Brittany, where Kopp was arrested on 29 March 2001 picking up cash posted from New York.

  • What sentence did he get? 25 years to life from New York State in 2003, then life plus 10 years in federal court in 2007.

A Friday Night in Amherst

That Friday wasn't an ordinary Sabbath for the Slepians. Barnett and his boys had just come back from a memorial service for his late father at the family's synagogue. He went into the kitchen, and Kopp, who'd been waiting in the trees behind the house, fired once through the rear window.


Slepian was hit in the back and collapsed on the kitchen floor. His wife Lynne, a former nurse, and his sons watched him bleed to death before help could do anything. He was 52.


The worst part is that people knew something was coming. Only three days earlier police had warned abortion providers across upstate New York and Canada to expect a possible sniper attack. Amherst's assistant police chief, Frank Olesko, had told doctors to keep away from uncovered windows and watch for anyone hanging around. Slepian's back window looked straight out onto woodland.


FBI and ATF investigators outside Dr Barnett Slepian's brick house in Amherst, New York, surrounded by autumn trees and police tape, after the October 1998 shooting
FBI and ATF investigators at the Slepian home in Amherst, October 1998

A Doctor Who'd Been Living Under Siege

Slepian was one of the main doctors at a Buffalo clinic that mostly served poor and working-class women, a lot of whom travelled from neighbouring states to dodge waiting periods or parental consent rules back home. That made the clinic a magnet for Operation Rescue and other anti-abortion groups, and by the time he died Slepian had received hundreds of death threats.


He'd seen this coming more clearly than anyone. In 1994 he wrote a letter to The Buffalo News making the point that the movement's loudest voices always acted shocked and innocent when somebody more extreme took their rhetoric literally and shot a doctor. Four years later he became the proof of his own argument.


Then there was the website. Activists ran a page called the Nuremberg Files, which listed abortion providers' names and personal details and crossed out the ones who'd been killed. Slepian's name was struck through within hours of his death. For the other doctors on that list, it was about as clear a message as you could send.


The Remembrance Day Shootings

Slepian's murder didn't come out of nowhere. Investigators had been chasing a sniper who seemed to strike around 11 November, Remembrance Day in Canada, for years. The Maclean's report published the week after Slepian died laid out the pattern:


  • 8 November 1994, Vancouver: Dr Garson Romalis was shot in the left thigh through his kitchen window while eating breakfast. A second shot just missed him and he very nearly bled to death.

  • 10 November 1995, Ancaster, Ontario: Dr Hugh Short was hit in the right elbow while sitting in the second-floor den of his home near Hamilton.

  • 28 October 1997, Perinton, New York: A doctor near Rochester was cut by debris when a bullet came through a sliding glass door.

  • 11 November 1997, Winnipeg: Dr Jack Fainman was shot in the right shoulder through a back window, with the bullet stopping inches from his heart.


Every one of them survived, but the shootings worked exactly the way the gunman wanted. Romalis left town every November after his shooting, and in British Columbia the number of doctors performing abortions fell by more than 10 per cent in the three years afterwards, even as demand went up. The RCMP, the FBI and police in Vancouver, Winnipeg and Hamilton had formed a joint task force in 1997, but they admitted they couldn't protect every doctor at every window.



Who Was James Kopp?

James Charles Kopp was born in Pasadena, California, on 2 August 1954. The FBI later described him as 5ft 11in, slim, bespectacled and walking with a slight limp. He drifted into the hardline end of the anti-abortion movement and became a follower of the Lambs of Christ, a group known for chaining themselves to clinic doors. By his own estimate he'd been to more than 100 clinic protests.


Among fellow activists he was known as "Atomic Dog", and he was later linked to the Army of God, the underground network that openly celebrated violence against abortion providers. For a time he lived around St Albans in Vermont, and the car he was driving at the time of the shooting carried Vermont plates.


What he said later about choosing his target is chilling in how ordinary it sounds. Kopp claimed he'd picked Slepian's name out of a phone book, had never read anything about him and wasn't put up to it by anyone in Buffalo. He chose the house because the back window faced woodland, scouted the street about six times over a year and twice had the gun ready before he finally fired. On the night, he said, he leaned against a pine tree to steady the rifle.


The Rifle in the Woods

Kopp vanished, but he left plenty behind. Investigators found a rifle buried in the woods behind the Slepian house. It had been bought at a pawn shop in Tennessee, and a map with directions to that same shop turned up among Kopp's belongings.


Then there was a single hair recovered from the sniper's spot in the trees. The FBI matched its DNA to a toothbrush Kopp had left with a friend months earlier. Add the neighbours who'd seen his car in the area in the weeks before, and the Bureau had its man. It just didn't know where he was.


On the Ten Most Wanted List With Osama bin Laden

On 7 June 1999, Kopp became the 455th person ever placed on the FBI's Ten Most Wanted list. He was added the same day as Osama bin Laden, which tells you how seriously Washington was taking anti-abortion terrorism at the time. The Bureau said he hadn't been seen since 3 November 1998.


By then he was long gone. Kopp slipped through Mexico and then spent around a year in Ireland, living in hostels and taking temp jobs through employment agencies while picking up passports and driving licences in other names. Police later said he'd used as many as 27 aliases and looked nothing like the three photos on his wanted poster by the time they caught up with him.


It's worth comparing his flight with James Earl Ray's after the assassination of Martin Luther King thirty years earlier. Both men fired a single rifle shot from cover, both crossed borders on false papers and both were run down abroad.


Three FBI wanted poster photographs of James Charles Kopp wearing glasses, shown with and without a beard and moustache
James Kopp's FBI wanted photos. He was number 455 on the Ten Most Wanted list and was arrested in Dinan, France, in March 2001


Caught at a Post Office in Brittany

Kopp wasn't surviving on temp work alone. Back in Brooklyn, Loretta Marra and her partner Dennis Malvasi were posting him money. Malvasi wasn't exactly a stranger to the authorities either: he'd been convicted over three clinic bombings and an attempted fourth in New York in the 1980s.


What brought it all down was an informant. A man known only as "John" worked as a paid FBI informant for two years on the case, and his tip gave agents both Kopp's alias and his location. Police tracked a parcel of cash mailed from New York City and worked out exactly when and where it would be collected. Much like the Unabomber, the most wanted man in the country was undone by somebody who knew more than he realised.



At 10.25am on 29 March 2001, French police arrested Kopp in Dinan, roughly 400km from Paris, as he picked up the package. Marra and Malvasi were arrested the same day in Brooklyn. They later pleaded guilty to conspiring to help him avoid capture and in 2003 were sentenced to the 29 months they'd already served, then walked free.


The informant's story has a sour postscript. He told NBC he'd been promised a million dollars, but the money dribbled in over three years and came to about $650,000 in total. Canada's share, he was told, depended on Kopp being convicted there, which never happened.


The Death Penalty Deal

Getting Kopp home wasn't straightforward. France won't extradite anyone who might face execution, so it demanded guarantees first. On 7 June 2001, two years to the day after Kopp went onto the Ten Most Wanted list, Attorney General John Ashcroft announced that the US had agreed not to seek the death penalty. It came just four days before Timothy McVeigh was executed for the Oklahoma City bombing, so the contrast didn't go unnoticed. If you want the bigger picture of the extremism that defined that decade, our piece on Timothy McVeigh's radicalisation covers it.


Ashcroft said he agreed with Lynne Slepian that the priority was getting Kopp back to face trial, whatever it took. He was eventually returned to Buffalo.


James Kopp in a dark suit and glasses at a court appearance, flanked by another man and a police officer, with bookshelves behind them

A Confession and Two Trials

In late 2002, sitting in a Buffalo jail, Kopp gave The Buffalo News the interview everyone had been waiting for. He admitted firing the shot but insisted he'd only meant to wound Slepian. He said he aimed at the doctor's shoulder and was horrified to learn the bullet had hit bone and caused fatal internal injuries. He said he regretted the death and felt sorry for Lynne and the boys. He also claimed Slepian had been about to end the lives of 25 babies, which tells you where the regret stopped.


Kopp skipped a jury and opted for a bench trial in front of Erie County Judge Michael D'Amico, who found him guilty of second-degree murder in March 2003. On 9 May he got the maximum, 25 years to life. D'Amico didn't buy the shoulder story either, finding it hard to believe Kopp expected Slepian to survive. District Attorney Frank Clark said that if the law had let him, he'd have asked for 100 years to life.


The federal case followed in 2007. Kopp told the court he'd come to believe the best way to stop abortion was to badly injure a provider, because "the doctor is the one essential thing". He compared himself to the people who plotted against Hitler until the judge told him to stop. The prosecutor's answer to the wounding defence was blunt: if you only want to hurt someone, "you don't shoot them with a high-powered rifle." The jury convicted him on 25 January 2007 of violating the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances (FACE) Act.


On 19 June 2007, US District Judge Richard Arcara gave him life plus 10 years, the extra decade for using a firearm in a violent crime. Arcara told Kopp he'd made himself prosecutor, judge, jury and executioner all at once. The federal appeals court upheld the sentence in 2009.



Where Is James Kopp Now?

Kopp is serving life in a federal prison. He hasn't given up, though. A year after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v Wade, he filed papers arguing that his federal convictions should be thrown out because the right to an abortion never existed in the first place. It's a non-starter: the FACE Act is still on the books, and even if he won, his New York State sentence would keep him inside.


The Canadian victims never got their day in court. Ontario had charged Kopp with attempted murder over the Hugh Short shooting, and investigators said hair found inside a ski mask linked him to it through DNA. But the charges were dropped in 2009 with no real explanation, and none of the three Canadian shootings has ever been resolved.


What Slepian Left Behind

The fallout hit the Buffalo clinic hard. Its administrator, Marilyn Buckham, said staff kept leaving in the months after the murder. In April 1999 Lynne Slepian and the four children met Hillary Clinton privately at the White House while the manhunt was still on.


The family's most lasting response came from Slepian's niece, Amanda Robb. She became an investigative journalist and went on to interview Kopp himself, and later reported on Scott Roeder, the man who murdered the Kansas doctor George Tiller in 2009. In 2022 she co-presented the CBC podcast Someone Knows Something: The Abortion Wars, which went back over the Canadian shootings and the case against Kopp. Twenty-eight years on, those Canadian cases are still officially open.

Further Reading

If you want the full story of the manhunt, Jon Wells' Sniper: The True Story of Anti-Abortion Killer James Kopp is the full-length account of Kopp, the sniper attacks and the international manhunt that ended in France. For the wider background, James Risen and Judy L. Thomas's Wrath of Angels: The American Abortion War tells how the movement's militant fringe grew out of the clinic blockades of the 1980s.


As an Amazon Associate, Utterly Interesting earns from qualifying purchases.

You Might Also Like


Sources

  1. The New York Times: Abortion Provider Is Shot to Death at Home (1998)

  2. Jewish Currents: Dr Slepian's Assassination

  3. Salon: report on the Slepian investigation and the Buffalo clinic (April 1999)

  4. Maclean's via The Canadian Encyclopedia: US Abortionist Slain (1998)

  5. Feminist Majority Foundation: Abortion Provider Murdered in Latest "Remembrance Day" Attack

  6. Southern Poverty Law Center: Anti-Abortion Extremism (2001)

  7. US Information Agency: FBI Ten Most Wanted announcement, 7 June 1999 (FAS archive)

  8. FBI: James Charles Kopp, Ten Most Wanted Fugitive

  9. Seven Days: Tiller's Death Recalls Vermont Ties to Anti-Abortion Violence (2009)

  10. CBS News: Report: Kopp Admits Killing Doctor

  11. Beliefnet: Abortion Foe Admits to Killing Doctor (2002)

  12. The Globe and Mail: How Police Sprang Trap on Fugitive "Atomic Dog" (2001)

  13. NBC News: Government Slow to Reward, Informant Says (2005)

  14. Feminist Majority Foundation: Kopp Accomplices Are Sentenced to Time Served, Released (2003)

  15. US Department of Justice: Attorney General's Statement on the Kopp Extradition (June 2001)

  16. The Guardian: Julian Borger on the Kopp verdict (March 2003)

  17. Feminist Majority Foundation: Kopp Receives 25 Years to Life for Murder (2003)

  18. CNN transcript: Kopp Sentencing Report, 9 May 2003

  19. CTV News: Anti-Abortion Extremist Takes Stand at US Trial (2007)

  20. Feminist Majority Foundation: Kopp Convicted on Federal Charges (2007)

  21. Feminist Majority Foundation: Kopp Sentenced to Life Plus 10 in Federal Court (2007)

  22. Feminist Majority Foundation: DNA Evidence Links Kopp to Another Shooting (2003)

  23. Yahoo News: James Kopp Says Conviction Should Be Tossed After Roe Ruling

  24. CBC News: Hamilton Abortion Doctor Shot in 1995 Featured in New Season of True-Crime Podcast (2022)

  25. Ms. Magazine: How Ms. Got the Story From George Tiller's Murderer (2010)


 
 

Recent Posts

See All
bottom of page