top of page

Before The Internet, What People Asked New York Public Library's Librarians?

  • Sep 25, 2018
  • 2 min read

Updated: Mar 13


Before the advent of the Internet and Google, the primary method of seeking answers to urgent inquiries was by visiting the local library and consulting the knowledgeable librarian.


In recent years, a collection of cards with queries directed to the librarian by patrons of the New York Public Library was unearthed by the staff. These queries were submitted either in person or via telephone. The telephone "ask a librarian" service was established in 1967 and remains operational today. Surprisingly, despite the accessibility of information at our fingertips, the New York Public Library still receives around 30,000 calls annually.

Hand holds note card with vintage telephone question statistics abandoned woman 1963.

“People have been reaching out to librarians for as long as there have been libraries,” Rosa Caballero-Li, the manager of Ask-NYPL, told Great Big Story. “Often time people do not have access to the technology at home,” she explains, “and I honestly think some just want somebody to talk to.”

From Monday to Saturday, between 9 AM and 6 PM, individuals have the opportunity to call 917-275-6975 and engage in a conversation with one of the ten staff members on duty. There are always at least five staff members ready to answer calls at any given time.


The majority of callers inquire about library services, while some seek to verify information they have heard in the news. Questions related to news, science, and history are received approximately once per hour. Additionally, individuals contact the service for assistance with basic grammar queries.

Typed question: "When did Moses first come into the public eye?" Dec 31, 1963.

Over the decades the library has received some of the most bizarre questions: Why do 18th Century English paintings have so many squirrels in them, and how did they tame them so that they wouldn't bite the painter? What is the life cycle of an eyebrow hair? How many neurotic people were in the United States? What does it mean when you dream you’re being chased by an elephant? One person just wanted to know how to put up a wallpaper. “I have the paper; I have the paste. What do I do next? Does the paste go on the wall or the paper? I've tried both and it doesn't seem to work.”



"There are no stupid questions," Caballero-Li admits. "Everything is a teachable moment. We don't embarrass people; we try to answer any questions they have with honesty and we try to refer them to appropriate resources that they might find useful."

The library keeps records of the most absurd and memorable questions asked to them. Some of these date as far back as the 1940s. Here, we have reposted a few from their Instagram account.


Handwritten note: "When, before 1866, was there no full moon in February?"


Handwritten note asks, "How do I gout up wallpages?" with installation query.



Handwritten note asks "Can mice 'throw up'?", dated EB 5/25/49.


Old handwritten note, "May a funeral be held July 4? 7/10/45."


Handwritten note quoting Albert Jay Nock: Exploitation is the second law of nature.



Old card with handwritten question: Is it proper to wear a veil at night time?


Handwritten note: "What latitude is New York City on?" phone call 6/2/59.


Handwritten note asks: 'West Point Cadets throw hats, do they get them back?'



Handwritten card asks: "If a poisonous snake bites itself, will it die?" 22 Sep 49.


Handwritten note: Charles Darwin's book. Oranges & peaches. dated 7/22/02.


Vintage card asks about water usage during a 1940 shortage.


Handwritten note: 'Isn't good poetry where every other line rhymes,' dated 1944.


Old library card with typewritten request for book about Helen of Troy.


Old card asks 'How do you spell Spizzerinctum?' dated Feb.1949.


Old index card: "Inquiry at desk, 1940" about country colors.


Old index card with query about "ATHAT" science, "TKL 29 June 1949".



Historical document: 'Do you have information about permanent people?' dated 2.9/60.


Handwritten note: "asked for Nutritional value of human flesh. DCW 4/6/58".


Index card reads: Off-hand do you know good books about twins?


Vintage note asks: IS THERE A FULL MOON EVERY NIGHT IN ACAPULCO?




 
 
bottom of page