top of page

Richard 'Two Gun' Hart: The Capone Brother Who Became a Prohibition Cowboy

Jan 25
11 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

Collage of Richard Two Gun Hart, Al Capone's eldest brother, in cowboy gear with family photos and a newspaper clipping about his career as a lawman

In the spring of 1919 a man in cowboy clothes climbed off a freight train in Homer, Nebraska, a farm town of about 500 people. He said his name was Richard Hart. He said he'd punched cattle in Oklahoma, toured with a circus and been decorated in France by General Pershing himself.


Almost none of it was true. His real name was Vincenzo Capone, and while he spent the 1920s smashing stills and arresting bootleggers across the Plains, his little brother Al Capone was getting rich selling the stuff in Chicago. Hart kept that secret from his town, his bosses and for years even his wife. It only came out in 1951, when he walked into a Chicago courtroom, nearly blind, still wearing his ten gallon hat.

Quick Answers

  • Who was Two Gun Hart? Richard James Hart, born Vincenzo (James) Capone in Italy in 1892, was Al Capone's eldest brother and a Prohibition agent in Nebraska and the Dakotas.

  • Why did he change his name? He took the surname of silent cowboy star William S. Hart, and an Anglo name also got him past the anti Italian prejudice of the rural West.

  • Did he really win the Distinguished Service Cross? He claimed he did, but army checks found no record of his service or medals, and his American Legion post threw him out over it.

  • Did he ever kill anyone? Yes. A mechanic was shot dead during a 1923 car chase, and around 1930 Hart was charged with manslaughter over another killing. He was acquitted.

  • When did he die? He died of a heart attack at home in Homer on 1st October 1952, about a year after his identity went public.

Richard Two Gun Hart posing in a Western shirt with a gun belt and holster, hands resting near his belt

Vincenzo Capone, the Boy Who Wanted to Be a Cowboy

Vincenzo Capone was born on 28th March 1892 in southern Italy, the first child of barber Gabriele Capone and his wife Teresa. Most accounts place his birth in Angri, a town near Naples. The family emigrated to Brooklyn when he was small and kept growing until there were nine children, including Ralph, Frank and a boy born in 1899 called Alphonse.


Vincenzo didn't fit in the tenements. He spent as much time as he could on Staten Island, still mostly fields and woods back then, working around a stable and learning to ride. Travelling Wild West shows sealed it. Watching the sharpshooters and trick riders, he fell for the whole romantic idea of the West as a place where a man could be whoever he decided to be, which is how Miami University's Italian American project puts his early obsession.



At 16 he walked out. Family lore has him walking young Al down to the ferry and telling him he couldn't come any further. Nobody's sure why he left. One family story claims he'd killed someone defending his brothers, though no evidence for that has ever surfaced. Another says his father smashed a violin over his head when he caught him teaching himself to play. A HistoryNet profile by the Western historian R.K. DeArment simply says he left after a fight. Months later a postcard reached Brooklyn. He'd joined a circus.


Inventing Richard Hart

He took his new surname from William S. Hart, the biggest Western star of the silent era, and borrowed the actor's whole look along with it, right down to the 'Two Gun' nickname the star had made famous. He worked as a roustabout and rider with travelling shows, including the Miller Brothers' 101 Ranch outfit, picking up the trick riding, roping and shooting that would become his calling card.



There was a practical side to the reinvention too. Italians in early 20th century America were widely treated as racially suspect and politically dangerous, and outside the big cities an Italian surname could close doors to jobs, housing and public office. Hart went a step further than just changing his name. When people asked about his olive skin, he told them he was part Native American.


The War Record Nobody Could Find

Here's where the old version of this story usually goes wrong. Hart told everyone he'd ridden after Pancho Villa in Mexico, fought in France, risen to lieutenant and been pinned with the Distinguished Service Cross by General John Pershing. Jeff McArthur's 2015 biography, which leans heavily on interviews with both the Hart and Capone families, takes the military career at face value, and plenty of articles (including the earlier version of this one) repeated it.


Seated cowboy in a wide brimmed hat and leather chaps looking down, from the era of the travelling Wild West shows

The paperwork tells a different story. When Homer's American Legion post finally asked the army to check his service in the late 1930s, the army came back with no record of it, and no record of any medals. The post expelled him. DeArment's conclusion is blunt: whatever Hart did between 1917 and 1919, he wasn't the decorated war hero he claimed to be. A 2026 profile in the North Dakota Cowboy Hall of Fame's Cowboy Chronicle also flags the service as fabricated.


That doesn't prove he never served in any capacity, and a man enlisting under a made up name and birthplace could leave a confusing paper trail. But the DSC claim in particular should be treated as Hart's own story, not established fact.


Officer pinning a medal on a uniformed soldier at a First World War era awards ceremony
Hart claimed General John Pershing decorated him in France, but army checks later found no record of his service or medals

The Flood That Made Him a Local Hero

Whatever his past, Hart's arrival in Homer couldn't have gone better. On 19th May 1919 a flash flood tore through nearby Emerson. Hart waded in, pulled out a girl called Margaret O'Connor and then rescued the family of a local grocer named Winch. The grocer's 19 year old daughter, Kathleen, married him that September. They went on to have four sons: Richard Jr, William, Sherman and Harry.


Homer took to him fast. The town council made him marshal, the county sheriff deputised him, the local American Legion post elected him commander (awkward, given what came later) and he became district commissioner for the Boy Scouts. Kathleen had no idea she'd married a Capone.


Nebraska was a tense place that year. A few months after Hart stepped off that train, a mob in Omaha lynched Will Brown and burned the courthouse. It wasn't a great time or place to be seen as an outsider, and Hart worked hard not to be.



Two Gun Hart Goes to War on the Bootleggers

National Prohibition kicked in at the start of 1920, and that summer Nebraska Governor Sam McKelvie commissioned Hart as a Prohibition agent. He didn't waste any time. Within weeks he'd raided and destroyed five stills near Martinsburg, followed by more in Randolph, Spencer and Schuyler, often after going in undercover first to gather the evidence himself.


He played the part to the hilt. Hart wore boots with spurs, a ten gallon hat and a pair of pearl handled six shooters slung low on his hips, and he'd ride his horse through town even though he owned a car. Newspapers loved him. Temperance campaigners loved him even more. On a good night in Nebraska and the Dakotas he'd sometimes average seven raids, a detail the Coeur d'Alene Press dug out of the old reports. His biographer Jeff McArthur reckons he was the most feared name among Midwest bootleggers.


Two Gun Hart holding a rifle beside a seized moonshine still and containers marked Gasoline, Pure Gas
While Al Capone made a fortune from illegal booze in Chicago, his eldest brother was destroying stills from Nebraska to the Dakotas and Washington state

Prohibition enforcement was a mess almost everywhere. Agents were badly paid, often politically appointed and frequently on the take, and the rules were so leaky that even Winston Churchill managed to get a doctor's note to drink in 1931 America. Hart's reputation for being unbribable made him stand out. So did his habit of ignoring paperwork, procedure and anybody who told him to slow down.


The Shooting in South Sioux City

That recklessness caught up with him in the autumn of 1923. Hart had a tip that a bootlegger called John Haaker was selling liquor to the Winnebago, and he went to South Sioux City with fellow agent Walter Gumm and two young Winnebago men to make the arrest. During a chase, the agents fired at a car to shoot its tyres out. The driver, a 35 year old mechanic called Ed Morvace, was hit and died that night.


The killing split the region. Bootleggers and 'wets' talked openly about lynching Hart, while the Women's Christian Temperance Union raised money for his defence. Justice Department investigators eventually called the shooting "wholly uncalled for" and found the agents guilty of careless indifference. Hart got a reprimand and kept his badge.



On the Reservations: Hero, Renegade or Both?

By the mid 1920s the Bureau of Indian Affairs had hired Hart as a special agent to keep liquor off reservations, starting in South Dakota and working out of Standing Rock in North Dakota, then Cheyenne River and eventually the Spokane and Coeur d'Alene reservations out west. It was the same Bureau that ran the boarding schools built to strip Native children of their culture, and Hart's job sat squarely inside that system.


He was a complicated figure there. He learned Lakota and Omaha, worked closely with tribal police and was friends with the Fort Yates photographer Frank Fiske, who took a series of cowboy portraits of him. Tribal leaders are often credited with giving him the 'Two Gun' nickname. Some called him the Coyote. One Oglala account says others had a less flattering name for him, Soiko, which roughly translates as big hairy boogie man.


Richard Two Gun Hart in a hat holding a young Native American boy dressed in a feathered headdress and ceremonial clothing
Hart, posing with a Native boy, split opinion in the communities he policed. Some saw him as a hero, others as a renegade

His methods were rough too. In 1926 a jury convicted him of assault and battery after a raid at Fort Yates. A resident accused Hart's party of taking $220 during a search without a proper warrant, and when the man complained to the reservation superintendent, Hart went after him physically. The case also kicked off a row over whether federal agents could raid reservation homes without valid warrants at all.


There were proud moments as well. In the summer of 1927 Hart was one of a handful of Western lawmen picked to guard President Calvin Coolidge on his Black Hills holiday. In 1929, on the Coeur d'Alene Reservation in Idaho, he led the hunt for a farmer called Charles Cherrapin who'd killed his wife. Cherrapin gave himself up, reportedly because of Hart's reputation, and went to prison for second degree murder.


Al Capone's Brother on the Other Side of the Law

Meanwhile Al had cut his teeth in Brooklyn under Frankie Yale before moving to Chicago. By 1925 he was running the biggest bootlegging operation in the country. The brothers were technically in the same business, just pointing in opposite directions.


Did they ever meet in those years? McArthur says yes. A Chicago photographer called Tony Berardi later claimed he met the two of them together in 1924 and that Al cheerfully introduced his big brother as a Prohibition agent from Nebraska. The story goes that they agreed to stay out of each other's way. It's a great anecdote, but it rests on Berardi's recollection.


The Lincoln bank robbery

The other big Capone story attached to Hart is the robbery of the Lincoln National Bank on 17th September 1930, when a gang with Thompson submachine guns walked out with about $2.7 million in cash and securities, the biggest bank job in American history until the 1950 Brink's robbery. McArthur credits Hart with persuading Al to help get the loot back.


The documented version is messier. A 1992 Nebraska History study of the robbery shows that Capone gang member Gus Winkeler was arrested and charged, and that the Capone syndicate helped recover around $600,000 in bonds as part of a deal to stop Winkeler being tried in Nebraska. Most of the haul was never recovered, the bank closed and its liquidators didn't finish paying off its obligations until the end of 1932, according to bank failure records. So Capone's people did return some of the bonds, but for their own reasons, and Hart's role in that rests on family accounts.


In October 1931 Al was convicted of tax evasion and sentenced to 11 years.



A Second Killing and the Long Fall

Around 1930 Hart shot and killed a wanted Native man who resisted arrest. He was indicted for manslaughter and acquitted, but in April 1931 the Commissioner of Indian Affairs sacked him anyway. Hart blamed a feud with reservation superintendent Byron A. Sharp, whom he accused of misconduct, and demanded a hearing he never got.


After that, things went steadily downhill. He worked as a range detective chasing cattle rustlers, got a brief reinstatement as a special agent for the Winnebago and Omaha reservations in October 1935, and lost it within months. In 1936 relatives of a man he'd killed ambushed him and beat him with brass knuckles, and he lost the sight in one eye. A cataract slowly took most of the sight in the other.


Friends got him back in as Homer's town marshal and later justice of the peace, but he lost both jobs after being accused of stealing canned goods. He wasn't prosecuted. Then came the Legion's records check and his expulsion. His eldest son, Richard Jr, was later killed fighting in the Second World War.


Going Back to the Capones

By 1937, broke and going blind, Hart did the one thing he'd spent nearly 30 years avoiding. He got in touch with his family. Ralph Capone sent money and set him up with a monthly cheque, partly by paying him rent on a Wisconsin property. Somewhere along the way Hart finally told Kathleen who he really was, and she kept it to herself.


After Al got out of prison in 1939, the two brothers met again at Ralph's place in Wisconsin. In 1946 Hart took his youngest son Harry to a Capone family cabin to meet his famous uncle, by then wrecked by syphilis. According to the Crime Library's account, Hart told Harry not to get too close to Al.


Outed in a Chicago Courtroom

Ralph Capone had been jailed for tax evasion back in 1930, and in 1951 the government was after him again, this time for hiding assets, including that Wisconsin lodge, which Ralph had listed as belonging to one Richard James Hart. Hart was subpoenaed. He turned up in Chicago aged 59, almost blind, with his hat on.


Asked for his real name, he told them: James Vincenzo Capone. It made headlines across America. He then testified that the property was his, not Ralph's, taking responsibility for any tax owed. McArthur reckons that was effectively perjury, committed for the family that had kept him afloat when the law he'd served had dumped him. Newsweek's verdict was that he'd been "the white sheep of the family".


Elderly Richard Hart with a cane seated beside his wife Kathleen in a hat while a reporter leans in to question them in Chicago in 1951
Hart, second from left, sits next to his wife Kathleen as reporters question him in a federal grand jury anteroom in Chicago in 1951, waiting to testify about his brother Ralph's income

Two Gun Hart's Death and Legacy

Hart went home to Homer and never really recovered his health. He still talked about breaking into Western films. On 1st October 1952 he died of a heart attack at home, with Kathleen and Harry beside him. He was 60. He's buried in the Omaha Valley Cemetery on the hill above town, under the name he chose rather than the one he was born with.


Investigators never tied him to any of his brothers' crimes. What he left behind is harder to pin down. He was a genuinely brave lawman who also shot two men dead, a man who probably faked a war record and then lost everything when it came out, and a Capone who spent his whole adult life pretending not to be one. In 1990 TNT turned his story into a TV movie, The Lost Capone, with Adrian Pasdar playing Hart, and his great grandson, Dr Corey Hart, still tells the family story today.


It's tempting to see him as Al's opposite. Read his life closely and the brothers look more alike than either would have liked: restless, theatrical, fiercely loyal to family and never too bothered about the rules when the rules got in the way.

Suggested Reading

Want more on the Capone brothers? These are worth a look.


Two Gun Hart: Law Man, Cowboy and Long Lost Brother of Al Capone by Jeff McArthur. The only full biography of Hart, built on interviews with both sides of the family. Take the war chapters with a pinch of salt.


Al Capone: His Life, Legacy and Legend by Deirdre Bair. A family-sourced biography of Al that fills in the Brooklyn years the brothers shared.


As an Amazon Associate, Utterly Interesting earns from qualifying purchases.

You Might Also Like

Sources

  1. 'Two-Gun' Hart: The Prohibition Cowboy, R.K. DeArment, HistoryNet

  2. Richard 'Two-Gun' Hart (Frontier Lawman Series), Cowboy Chronicle, North Dakota Cowboy Hall of Fame, June 2026

  3. 'Two-Gun' Hart: An Italian American Cowboy, Italian American Collections, Miami University

  4. Al Capone: Chicago's Most Infamous Mob Boss, Two-Gun Hart, Marilyn Bardsley, Crime Library

  5. Huckleberries: Al Capone's brother in Coeur d'Alene, Coeur d'Alene Press, 2021

  6. Al Capone's secret brother in Nebraska, McCook Gazette, 2002

  7. Gangland Crime Arrives in Lincoln: The Lincoln National Bank and Trust Company Robbery of 1930, George Wilson, Nebraska History 73 (1992)

  8. Lincoln National Bank and Trust Company (Lincoln, NE), FinHist bank runs database

  9. Al Capone, FBI History

  10. The Brothers Capone (Part One), Allan May, AmericanMafia.com

  11. Al Capone's Lawman Brother: Richard 'Two Gun' Hart with Jeff McArthur, Most Notorious podcast, 2021

  12. AKA Capone, Andrew Ward, Medium

 
 
bottom of page